News Updates - 2023
NEWS: NEtwork Weekly Stuff
News Updates, Recent Meeting Notes, and Next Meeting Information
Upcoming - Everyone is welcome!
December 7th (Thursday) - 4:00-5:00 PM - Energy Working Group
January 3rd (Wednesday) - 7:00 PM - Climate Working Group
January 7th (Sunday) - 6:00-7:30 PM - Plastics Working Group — Legislative Focus
January 14th (Sunday ) - 6:00-7:30 PM - Plastics Working Group — Next Regular Meeting
What’s Happening at the NH Network 11/26/23
Seemingly, there are endless opportunities to connect and meet during the month of December. It can be overwhelming, but one hopes you will choose a couple or three to join.
-Good news on recycling:
https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox/FMfcgzGwHxsbrhTxqnbWMrLVDZMtDfMN
-Good news: the NH Saves Program approved by NH PUC. Thanks to all that sent letters.
-Good news as reported from Senator Shaeen’s office:
-Senator Shaheen celebrated the towns of Exeter, Peterborough and Harrisville that were
among only 12 projects nationwide selected for $900,000 through the Energy Efficiency
and Conservation Block Grant (EECBG) Program. Senator Shaheen was in Exeter to
discuss their project which will partner with NHSaves and Weatherization programs in
the state to bring energy efficient upgrades to over 100 manufactured homes.
Clean Energy NH was awarded $500,000 through USDA RD, Rural Energy for America
Program (REAP) Technical Assistance funding that was expanded through the Inflation
Reduction Act.
The National Fish and Wildlife Foundation (NFWF) and NOAA announced $144 million in new grants to support natural infrastructure projects in 31 coastal states and U.S. territories. Congratulations, to the Town of Durham ($1,994,500) and The Nature Conservancy-New Hampshire ($999,800) for their projects that were selected for funding.
-Here are two links for an upcoming 12/06 ISO Meeting in Boston. The first is written by Don Kreis and is worth your time.
https://indepthnh.org/2022/12/01/ratepayers-stage-a-ballroom-coup/
https://www.iso-ne.com/committees/industry-collaborations/consumer-liaison
-Meetings:
Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan…seeking public input for obtaining federal grants to reduce greenhouse effects: various dates and workshops to affect climate change in NH
-Plastics WG 12/3
-Energy WG 12/7
-Community Action Plan 12/06
-ISO NE Boston meeting 12/06
-Citizens Climate WG 12/6
-NH Agricultural Policy Forum 12/13
-League of Conservation Voters 12/14
-Sierra Club Volunteer Meeting 12/14
-Clean Energy NH 2024 Legislative Overview 12/20
-Take Action:
Attend any, all or some of the above listed meetings. Legislative action is around the corner.
-Feed Your Brain:
-Environmental and energy updates from Senator Shaeen’s office
-November 30, January 30 and February 8 Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
There are a series of community and public comments and sharing committees to enable NH to participate in a 4.6 billion dollar grant to reduce greenhouse emissions. The grant specifically asks for local input.
Three cross-sector shareholder gatherings where people working on greenhouse gas and air pollution reduction efforts, advocates, non-profits, regional and city/town planners, association leaders, etc. can talk together about priorities and projects that are essential elements of New Hampshire's PCAP (due March 1, 2024)
-December 6, January 9 and January 24 Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
UPDATE ON Climate Action Plan listening sessions: Several NH Network members attended the Nov 30 session. It was beautifully organized (well-moderated break-out sessions on different topics),and the opportunity to hear from one another was interesting and informative! Highly recommend you sign up for one, and report back! Moving forward we have number of community conversation opportunities both ONLINE and IN-PERSON for this first phase of work. They are occurring between December 6 th, 2023 and February 8 th, 2024.
Share the following link with people who can help move NH forward.
https://carsey.unh.edu/new-hampshire-listens/nhdes-updating-new-hampshires-climate-action-plan
Three community conversations: Between December 2023 and early February 2024, a series of community conversations will offer time for people to learn, listen, and talk with each other to help develop a priority climate action plan focused on air pollution reductions in New Hampshire. These conversations are focused on talking about local issues and potential solutions.
Important details on engagement, action goals and input are available at:
https://carsey.unh.edu/new-hampshire-listens/updating-new-hampshire-climate-action-plan
-Sunday, December 3 at 6 pm Plastics WG meeting.
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
Meeting ID 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
-Monday, December 7 at 4 pm Energy WG
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87570493142?pwd=sEOVZHyM6ZIVYXPcaHsaOAfS0Rnbia.1 Meeting ID: 875 7049 3142 Passcode: 425473
-Wednesday, Dec 6, 2023, 12:00 PM - 3:30 PM EST (Virtual option starts at 12:30.)
Independent System Operator (ISO) New England Customer Liaison Group meeting on operation of the NE grid. These links will explain why this meeting is so important.
https://indepthnh.org/2022/12/01/ratepayers-stage-a-ballroom-coup/
https://www.iso-ne.com/committees/industry-collaborations/consumer-liaison
WHERE: Colonnade Hotel, 120 Huntington Avenue, Boston MA 02116. Validated parking onsite. In-person registration is limited to 125 people and closes on Wed, Nov 29 at noon.
IN-PERSON registration is linked here.
VIRTUAL registration is linked here.
-Wednesday, December 6th at 7 pm Citizens Climate WG
https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz09
Or by phone: 1-929-205-6099 9831200408# 1632#
-Wednesday, December 13th 8:15 am to 9 30 am 2023 Annual NH Policy Forum highlighting up coming legislation
Nhttps://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/rP0x0me446I
-Thursday, December 14 11 30 to 1 pm League of Conservation Voters: Clean Energy and Climate Action in 2024 - A New Hampshire and National Perspective
Saint Paul’s Episcopal Church 21 Centre Street Concord, NH
Join the League of Conservation Voters and partners as we look forward To January of 2024 with a full docket of clean energy and climate action proposals which is set to be considered by New Hampshire lawmakers.
Speakers will provide insight and analysis on the 2024 New Hampshire policy landscape with continued funding for energy efficiency investments, advocacy for more renewable energy sources and the development of offshore wind as just a few of the topics at hand. The program will also provide updates on federal funding from both the infrastructure bill and the Inflation Reduction Act.
For more information, contact League of Conservation Voters New Hampshire State Director Director Rob Werner at rob_werner@lcv.org. (603) 674-9810 (mobile)
-Thursday, December 14 7 pm Sierra Club Volunteer Meeting including an update on the Bow Power Plant
https://www.mobilize.us/climateactionnh/event/584089/
-Wednesday, December 20th at 2 pm Clean Energy NH
Here's a link to a December 20th Clean Energy NH Preview of the 2024 Legislative Season. Energy committee members might consider asking their towns to join CENH as municipal members for $250 a year. I got our Select Board to join CENH this year and we have put this cost into our budget request for next year. This is a very good way to access CENH insights on legislation and other energy policy in New Hampshire. (And you get two tickets to the Local Energy Solutions conference, worth $200!)
-Here are federal energy and environment updates from Senator Shaheen’s office
Below are Federal environment and energy (E&E) updates from the past month. I am also
attaching last month’s newsletter as a reminder of grant announcements from the previous
month. Please do not hesitate to reach out if Senator Shaheen can be helpful to you and your
community or organization.
Senator Shaheen Updates:
Senator Shaheen recently became Chair of the Senate Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee. Senator Shaheen’s first hearing will be tomorrow, Wednesday, November 1 at 2:30 on the topic of “The Great Outdoors: Small Businesses and America’s Outdoor Recreation Economy.” New Hampshire Small Business Owner, Andrew Drummond of Ski the Whites will be one of the witnesses for the hearing. The hearing will be livestreamed on the Senate Small Business and
Entrepreneurship Committee website.
NH Municipal Association and Senator Shaheen’s office held a webinar about Elective
Pay, a provision of Inflation Reduction Act. Elective pay allows applicable entities,
including tax-exempt and governmental entities that would otherwise be unable to claim
certain credits because they do not owe federal income tax, to benefit from some clean
energy tax credits. By choosing this election, the amount of the credit is treated as a
payment of tax and any overpayment will result in a refund. You can re-watch the
webinar and access further resources about elective pay here.
New Hampshire Congressional Delegation Applauds Twin States Clean Energy Link’s
Selection to be Part of $1.3 Billion U.S. Department of Energy Program.
Senator Shaheen celebrated the towns of Exeter, Peterborough and Harrisville that were
among only 12 projects nationwide selected for $900,000 through the Energy Efficiency
and Conservation Block Grant (EECBG) Program. Senator Shaheen was in Exeter to
discuss their project which will partner with NHSaves and Weatherization programs in
the state to bring energy efficient upgrades to over 100 manufactured homes.
Clean Energy NH was awarded $500,000 through USDA RD, Rural Energy for America
Program (REAP) Technical Assistance funding that was expanded through the Inflation
Reduction Act.
U.S. Senator Jeanne Shaheen, a senior member of the U.S. Senate Appropriations Subcommittee
that funds the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), announced with the
NH delegation that $27.6 million in LIHEAP funds are being awarded to New Hampshire to
assist Granite State families ahead of the winter season with fuel assistance. Granite Staters can
apply for heating assistance through their local Community Action Partnership office. Please visit
CAPNH.org to find an office near you.'
U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture (NIFA) announced
an investment of nearly $3.4 Million in New Technologies for Ag Extension at the University of
New Hampshire.
New Hampshire will receive a Department of Energy (DOE) award totaling $6,619,797
to help modernize the state’s power grid. The funding will be used to invest in
disadvantaged communities, bolster grid resilience for extreme weather and other disruptive events and provide additional workforce development and training
opportunities. New Hampshire will hold a competitive selection process to identify
projects in need of this funding. These grants were funded by the Bipartisan
Infrastructure Law.
U.S. Senators Jeanne Shaheen and Susan Collins announced their bipartisan resolution to
designate October 4, 2023, as “Energy Efficiency Day” passed the Senate unanimously.
The resolution celebrates and promotes the economic and environmental benefits gained
from investing in energy efficiency.
Federal Grants & Programs Announced:
*New*: The White House is updating a running list of IRA funding opportunities here
and BIL funding opportunities here. I will keep highlighting major Notice of Funding
Announcements for energy and environment projects below but be sure to check these
list frequently for updates of all open funding.
For a complete list of IRA and BIL grants & programs please check out the IRA
Guidebook and the BIL Guidebook.
The Biden Administration released a technical assistance guide which helps communities
navigate, access, and deploy infrastructure, climate resilience and clean energy funding.
The guide provides comprehensive information about more than 100 federal technical
assistance programs that can support efforts to win Federal funding and deploy it in
communities across the nation.
Below are a couple of grants and programs that were announced last month. Please reach out if
Senator Shaheen can be helpful in identifying grants or writing a letter of support for a federal
grant.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced the availability of $235 million in
grants to assess and clean up polluted brownfield sites across the country. The new grants through
EPA’s Brownfields Multipurpose, Assessment, and Cleanup (MAC) program will advance
environmental justice and help transform what were once polluted, vacant, and abandoned
properties into community assets while spurring economic revitalization in underserved
communities.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service is making nearly $50 million in grant
funding available for proposals that support crucial links between resilient, healthy forests, strong
rural economies and jobs in the forestry sector. The open funding opportunity comes through the
Forest Service’s three key grant programs to support the forest products economy: Wood
Innovations Grant, Community Wood Grant, and Wood Products Infrastructure Assistance Grant
Programs. The agency is seeking proposals that support innovative uses of wood in the
construction of low carbon buildings, as a renewable energy source, and in manufacturing and
processing products. These programs also provide direct support to expand and retrofit wood
energy systems and wood products manufacturing facilities nationwide.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service announced the availability of up to $36 million through
President Biden’s Investing in America agenda for fish passage projects across the nation that
address outdated, unsafe or obsolete dams, culverts, levees and other barriers fragmenting our
nation’s rivers and streams.
FEMA is making $1.8 billion available for two grant programs designed to help communities
increase their resilience to the impacts of climate change, including increasingly frequent and
extreme weather events. The Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC) annual
grant program is making $1 billion available for projects that protect people and infrastructure
from natural hazards and the effects of climate change. The Flood Mitigation Assistance program
is making $800 million available.
November 26, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Overview
This week’s summary offers action and meeting opportunities. Time sensitive action is supporting net metering. Ideally, you can take time today to contact the various stake players.
There is an important and simple action item on PFAS within NH and within North Carolina.
Meetings and Events
Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan…seeking public input for obtaining federal grants to reduce greenhouse effects
-Plastics WG 12/3
-Energy WG 12/7
-ISO NE Boston meeting 12/06
-Citizens Climate WG 12/6
-NH Agricultural Policy Forum 12/13
-Clean Energy NH 2024 Legislative Overview 12/20
Take Action
-Sierra Club PFAS petition
-Take action before 11/27 on contacting the PUC re: net metering pricing.
-Take action to support Rep. Aron’s letter concerning PFAS leakage into the Ammonoosuc River
Feed Your Brain
-Coal particulates are worse for human health than previously thought.
-Bow power plant fails “stack” test. Exceeds federal limits by 70%.
-The National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC) and White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council (WHEJAC) meetings and listening sessions.
Meetings and Events
-November 30, January 30 and February 8 Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
There are a series of community and public comments and sharing committees to enable NH to participate in a 4.6 billion dollar grant to reduce greenhouse emissions. The grant specifically asks for local input.
Three cross-sector shareholder gatherings where people working on greenhouse gas and air pollution reduction efforts, advocates, non-profits, regional and city/town planners, association leaders, etc. can talk together about priorities and projects that are essential elements of New Hampshire's PCAP (due March 1, 2024)
-December 6, January 9 and January 24 Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
Three community conversations: Between December 2023 and early February 2024, a series of community conversations will offer time for people to learn, listen, and talk with each other to help develop a priority climate action plan focused on air pollution reductions in New Hampshire. These conversations are focused on talking about local issues and potential solutions.
Important details on engagement, action goals and input are available at:
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/wIpv0xpjw64
-Sunday, December 3 at 6 pm Plastics WG meeting.
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
Meeting ID 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
-Monday, December 7 at 4 pm Energy WG
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87570493142?pwd=sEOVZHyM6ZIVYXPcaHsaOAfS0Rnbia.1
Meeting ID: 875 7049 3142 Passcode: 425473
-Wednesday, Dec 6, 2023, 12:00 PM - 3:30 PM EST (Virtual option starts at 12:30.)
Independent System Operator (ISO) New England Customer Liaison Group meeting on operation of the NE grid.
WHERE: Colonnade Hotel, 120 Huntington Avenue, Boston MA 02116. Validated parking onsite. In-person registration is limited to 125 people and closes on Wed, Nov 29 at noon.
IN-PERSON registration is linked here.
VIRTUAL registration is linked here.
-Wednesday, December 6th at 7 pm Citizens Climate WG
https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz09
Or by phone: 1-929-205-6099 9831200408# 1632#
-Wednesday, December 13th 8:15 am to 9 30 am 2023 Annual NH Policy Forum highlighting up coming legislation
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/rP0x0me446I
-Wednesday, December 20th at 2 pm Clean Energy NH
Here's a link to a December 20th Clean Energy NH Preview of the 2024 Legislative Season. Energy committee members might consider asking their towns to join CENH as municipal members for $250 a year. I got our Select Board to join CENH this year and we have put this cost into our budget request for next year. This is a very good way to access CENH insights on legislation and other energy policy in New Hampshire. (And you get two tickets to the Local Energy Solutions conference, worth $200!)
Take Action
-PFAS in any state is a threat to all states. Consider signing this petition.
I just signed this petition from Sierra Club North Carolina, calling on EPA Administrator Michael Regan to halt permission for Chemours to import 4 million pounds of PFAS waste from the Netherlands to its Fayetteville NC plant. This is an issue of national significance, as imported wastes could be sent to landfills or incinerators around the country.
https://act.sierraclub.org/actions/NorthCarolina?actionId=AR0403726
After your sign, please pass on this request to fellow activists.
Thank you.
Tracy Frisch
Clean Air Action Network of Glens Falls (NY)
-Join one of the Department of Energy public sessions to make federal funds available for limiting greenhouse emissions. (Details offered above.)
-The NH Public Utilities Commission (PUC) will be considering setting a new Net Metering rate for NH residents, business, and local governments. The decision will be issued next May, June, or July. It's a way off. However, the DOE has to develop and submit a position on what that should be by December 1. The docket number is DE 22-060
Likely, this will be a contentious issue when the case formally begins at the PUC. The DOE/State of NH's position could be a large influence on final order. As you likely know, the Governor has been skeptical of small scale solar throughout his political career. He has shown a willingness to support it on occasion.
Ideally, letters would get to the Governor and/or DOE by Nov 27. In terms of content,
The letters do NOT need to be perfect. It would be better to get more contacts from local governments, energy committees, or businesses than a few immaculate arguments.
Economic arguments (this is good for our taxpayers) may be more influential than environmental arguments (fortunately what's good for the economy/taxpayers is good for GHG emissions.
Ideally individualized copies would be sent to both DOE and Gov.
DOE Commissioner: Jared Chicoine - jared.s.chicoine@energy.nh.gov
Governor: governorsununu@nh.gov
For DOE consider cc'd DOE staff (pick 1?)
DOE DIrector of Regulatory Support: Tom Frantz - Thomas.C.Frantz@energy.nh.gov
Renewable Energy Division: deandra.m.perruccio@energy.nh.gov
General: energy-info@energy.nh.gov
-At a Third Act NH virtual event, Kendra Ford of 350NH / NoCoal No Gas encouraged turnout at the Independent System Operator (ISO) New England Customer Liaison Group meeting on December 6th in Boston, beginning at 12 PM.
This meeting is open to consumers and others who are interested in the operation of the grid, via either a virtual or a live option.
You need to register for the event and there is. (Sign up options are listed above.)
- Below is a letter Rep. Judy Aron sent to the DES in response to Jon Swan's report (also below) of PFAS compounds in samples he took from the Ammonoosuc River -- which had seeped from the NCES Landfill. (Given that DES has been reluctant to expand its monitoring responsibilities in other locations, this letter seems especially timely.)
PLEASE ADD YOUR VOICE -- Praise Chairperson Aron of the House Environment & Agriculture Committee for her leadership and especially for her concern over PFAS.
Your letter will go to the House Env & Ag Comm, the Senate Energy & Natural Resources Committee, and DES Robert Scott and Mike Wimsatt if you copy the addresses from Representative Aron's letter. ( I had to tinker with these emails a bit, but they will “go.”)
judy.aron@leg.state.nh.us
<robert.scott@des.nh.gov>; Wimsatt, Mike <michael.j.wimsatt@des.nh.gov>; Mike Wimsatt <michael.wimsatt@des.nh.gov>
Cc: saveforestlake@yahoo.com <saveforestlake@yahoo.com>; ~House Environment and Agriculture Committee <houseenvironmentandagriculturecommittee@leg.state.nh.us>; Kevin Avard <kevin.avard@leg.state.nh.us>; ~Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee <senateenergyandnaturalresources@leg.state.nh.us>; Crepeau, Adam <adam.j.crepeau@nh.gov>; Jeb Bradley <jeb.bradley@leg.state.nh.us>; Sherman Packard <sherman.packard@leg.state.nh.us>
Judy Aron <judy...@leg.state.nh.us>; Robert Scott <robert...@des.nh.gov>; Wimsatt, Mike <michael....@des.nh.gov>; Mike Wimsatt <michael...@des.nh.gov>; savefor...@yahoo.com <savefor...@yahoo.com>; ~House Environment and Agriculture Committee <houseenvironmentand...@leg.state.nh.us>; Kevin Avard <kevin...@leg.state.nh.us>; ~Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee <senateenergyand...@leg.state.nh.us>; Crepeau, Adam <adam.j....@nh.gov>; Jeb Bradley <jeb.b...@leg.state.nh.us>; Sherman Packard <sherman...@leg.state.nh.us>
Dear Commissioner Scott and Director Wimsatt,
As Chair of the House Environment and Agriculture Committee, I have been receiving correspondence regarding dangerous PFAS compounds reportedly leaking into the Ammonoosuc River from the NCES landfill (as stated in the email below). I would like to know what immediate steps your department is taking to verify and deal with what appears to be an environmental crisis unfolding in the Ammonoosuc River.
This is of urgent matter and must be dealt with immediately as it not only constitutes a violation of the Clean Water Act, but it threatens the health and well being of everyone living in that area!
Please reply to me and my committee. as well as to my Senate counterparts, as to what actions you as state regulators tasked with monitoring this kind of contaminant pollution, are pursuing regarding this contaminant runoff and/or leachate from the NCES landfill, and if there is anything legislatively that needs to be done immediately to support your work to contain and eliminate this and further contamination.
I await your prompt reply as I am very concerned about this matter.
Thank you,
Judy Aron
NH State Representative
Sullivan County District 4
(From Jon Swan)
Good Morning Ms. LeClair et al.,
Considering that I have not heard anything from EPA regarding my concerns that the NCES Landfill is failing to contain harmful contaminants from being released upgradient of and into the surrounding watershed of the Ammonoosuc River, I conducted my own "water sampling" of the water emerging from the "Main Seep" via the surface water channel, discharging directly into the Ammonoosuc River.
My sample was taken directly from the water cascading off of the NCES property via the seep drainage channel on Friday morning, October 20, 2023. The surface water was flowing strongly off the property's edge, in such a way that it allowed me to collect my sample without trespassing on NCES property. My access into the Ammonoosuc River was granted by a property owner on the other side of the river, and my sampling was witnessed by that property owner. I was up to my waist and armpits in the Ammonoosuc River the entire time, and it was cold!
I have attached the lab report, which I just received last Thursday, November 9, 2023. I did not test for any other contaminants, like 1,4-Dioxane, solely PFAS.
On pages 2-3 of the report, you can read that there were 3 detections of PFAS contaminants being released directly into the Ammonoosuc River:
Perfluorobutanesulfonic Acid (PFBS) 4.35 ng/L
Perfluorohexanoic Acid (PFHxA) 4.73 ng/L
Perfluorooctanoic Acid (PFOA) 2.39 ng/L
Page 10 also shows a result of 1.37 ng/L for Perfluoroheptanoic Acid (PFHpA), a “J” qualifier, thus below the reporting limit but apparently above the laboratory method detection limit (MDL).
I would note that these 4 PFAS compounds are the same top 4 found PFAS compounds consistently detected in NCES leachate lab reports, from 2018-2023, obtained from NHDES and the City of Concord WWTPs. Basically, the contaminants detected entering the Ammonoosuc River at the Seep drainage channel match the PFAS profile of NCES Landfill leachate. The same can be said for the numerous detections and exceedances of PFAS contaminants at the upgradient B-304 and B-928 wells.
It would seem to me that this release of contaminants directly into the Ammonoosuc River is a violation of the Clean Water Act.
I must admit, it is disturbing to think that a concerned citizen has been forced into this action, because both state and federal regulators have failed to do so.
I do hope the EPA and the Town of Bethlehem will take this latest revelation seriously. I can only imagine the volume of contaminants being released into the Ammonoosuc River, via the drainage channel surface water discharge. It has become quite clear to me that the relationship between SHA/Casella and NHDES officials has become compromised. An investigation into what is occurring at the NCES Landfill is warranted, and I believe this lab report provides concrete evidence in support of my prior charges that the landfill is failing.
All of this, of course, is my opinion, based on my research and experience. Thank you!
Feed Your Brain
-(from Marybeth Raven)
Hey NH Network energy folks,
I just want to point out this NYT article about how Coal particulates are worse for human health than previously thought.
This is an opportunity for us to mention this sad fact in the upcoming DEC "Listening sessions" about the NH Climate action plan. NH has the last large coal burning facility in New England -- in Bow, NH. When this this is running, it provides electricity to the ISO network in general -- so the electricity is most likely going to Boston, or other populated areas -- yet the residents of NH -- particularly Bow-- suffer the health consequences.
-Bow coal plant fails “stack test”
https://newhampshirebulletin.com/2023/11/22/federally-reportable-violations-followed-failed-stack-test-at-merrimack-station-state-says/
-There is a lot here, but choose a webinar to attend.
The National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC) and White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council (WHEJAC) will host a meeting, each, in early December. The meetings are free and open to all members of the public. Individual registration for the events is REQUIRED. The meetings require registration for participants to submit comments orally or written.
National Environmental Justice Advisory Council (NEJAC) – REGISTER HERE!
NEJAC will convene a virtual public meeting on Tuesday, December 5, 2023, 10:00 AM to 7:30 PM ET. The meeting discussions will focus on several topics including, but not limited to, updates on NEJAC recommendations related to air quality and community monitoring, PFAS, finance and investments and responses to community concerns brought forward in Puerto Rico.
Public Comment Period: Those who wish to participate during the public comment period must register by 11:59 p.m. ET, November 28, 2023. Written comments can be submitted up to two weeks after the meeting closes on December 19, 2023.
Individuals or groups making remarks during the oral public comment period will be limited to three (3) minutes. Please be prepared to briefly share your comments; including your recommendations on what you want the NEJAC to advise EPA to do. Submitting written comments for the record are strongly encouraged.
The NEJAC is interested in receiving public comments relevant to the following charges:
Cumulative Impacts Framework Charge
Farmworker and Pesticides Charge
The public can submit written comments in three (3) different ways:
by using the webform: https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/forms/national-environmental-justice-advisory-council-nejac-public-comment
by sending comments via email to ne...@epa.gov.
by creating comments in the Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OEJECR-2023-0101 at http://www.regulations.gov, when it opens.
Questions: Please contact Paula Flores-Gregg at ne...@epa.gov or by phone 214-665-8123.
Learn more about NEJAC: https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/national-environmental-justice-advisory-council
_______________________________________________________________
White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council (WHEJAC) – REGISTER HERE!
WHEJAC will convene a virtual public meeting Wednesday, December 6, 2023 2:00 - 7:45 PM ET.
Public Comment Period: Those who wish to participate during the public comment period must register by 11:59 PM ET, November 29, 2023. Written comments can be submitted through December 20, 2023.
The WHEJAC is interested in receiving public comments relevant to current charges, topics, and questions currently under consideration:
The Climate and Economic Justice Screening Tool
The Environmental Justice Scorecard
Carbon Management
Ways that the WHEJAC could recommend advancing environmental justice through a whole-government approach.
Examples of environmental hazards of particular concern for Indigenous Peoples and Tribal Nations related to Federal activities that may affect sacred sites and areas of cultural significance, cultural or other traditions or practices, subsistence, and ways of life.
Ways in which the Federal government can address community impacts, and concerns of Indigenous Peoples and Tribal Nations.
Ways in which the incorporation of Indigenous knowledge into Federal decision-making could help address environmental hazards and environmental justice concerns.
More information on each charge: https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/white-house-environmental-justice-advisory-council under WHEJAC Membership and Workgroups.
The public can submit written comments in 3 different ways:
By entering comments in the Docket ID No. EPA-HQ-OEJECR-2023-0099 at https://www.regulations.gov/
By using the webform at https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/forms/white-house-environmental-justice-advisory-council-whejac-public-comment
By sending comments via email to whe...@epa.gov, for comments with additional materials.
November 20, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Overview
Perhaps the most important action item available to the Network. Last Thursday Kent Street Coalition offered a two hour webinar on “Untipping the Judiciary.” It included national wide organizations Demand Justice and the American Constitution Society as well as remarks from Andru Volinsky and Cinde Warmington. Their message: Power lays with the federal judges, and they increasing decide elections and the most important cultural issues.
According to the webinar, Donald Trump appointed nearly one quarter of all federal judges, and Biden has done a decent job, but there are many remaining openings. In the last months he has sent only a handful to the Senate which appoints federal judges. The House is not involved. Action is simple. Contact Senators Shaneen and Hassan, and contact them to push forward on as many nominations within the next year.
AND, the next NH governor will select two supreme court judges in 2026
From the newly formed Energy WG
Please fill out this Energy Working Group Members Survey.
The survey will give us a sense of who's currently in the newly formed NH Network Energy Working Group and what members would like to focus our monthly meetings on.
Please respond to the survey by by Monday December 4th so we can share the results at the December 7th 4:00 - 5:00 meeting:
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87570493142?pwd=sEOVZHyM6ZIVYXPcaHsaOAfS0Rnbia.1 Meeting ID: 875 7049 3142 Passcode: 425473
Meetings and Events
Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan…seeking public input for obtaining federal grants to reduce greenhouse effects
Plastics WG 12/3
Energy WG 12/7
ISO NE Boston meeting 12/06
Climate WG 12/6
Clean Energy NH 2024 Legislative Overview 12/20
Take Action
Regional news letter: a model for the future?
Attend NH Department of Energy listening sessions on Climate Action plans and potential
grants.
Take action before 11/27 on contacting the PUC re: net metering pricing.
North Country donation request
Feed Your Brain
Plastics WG minutes
Video recording of Networks 11/13 on the “Military and the Challenge of Climate Change.”
Update on Casella’s garbage landslide in NY.
Jon Swan’s update on chemicals in the Ammonoosuc River
Meetings and Events
November 30, January 30 and February 8 - Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
There are a series of community and public comments and sharing committees to enable NH to participate in a 4.6 billion dollar grant to reduce greenhouse emissions. The grant specifically asks for local input.
Three cross-sector shareholder gatherings where people working on greenhouse gas and air pollution reduction efforts, advocates, non-profits, regional and city/town planners, association leaders, etc. can talk together about priorities and projects that are essential elements of New Hampshire's PCAP (due March 1, 2024)
December 6, January 9 and January 24 Department of Energy: Climate Action Plan
Three community conversations: Between December 2023 and early February 2024, a series of community conversations will offer time for people to learn, listen, and talk with each other to help develop a priority climate action plan focused on air pollution reductions in New Hampshire. These conversations are focused on talking about local issues and potential solutions.
Important details on engagement, action goals and input are available at:
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/wIpv0xpjw64
Sunday, December 3 at 6 PM — Plastics Working Group meeting.
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
Meeting ID 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
Wednesday, December 6 at 12:00 PM - 3:30 PM EST (Virtual option starts at 12:30 PM.)
Independent System Operator (ISO) New England Customer Liaison Group meeting on operation of the NE grid.
WHERE: Colonnade Hotel, 120 Huntington Avenue, Boston MA 02116. Validated parking onsite. In-person registration is limited to 125 people and closes on Wed, Nov 29 at noon.
IN-PERSON registration is linked here.
VIRTUAL registration is linked here.
Wednesday, December 6th at 7 PM - Climate Working Group
https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz09
Or by phone: 1-929-205-6099 9831200408# 1632#
Thursday, December 7 at 4 PM — Energy Working Group
https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87570493142?pwd=sEOVZHyM6ZIVYXPcaHsaOAfS0Rnbia.1 Meeting ID: 875 7049 3142 Passcode: 425473
Wednesday, December 20th at 2 PM — Clean Energy NH
Here's a link to a December 20th Clean Energy NH Preview of the 2024 Legislative Season. Energy committee members might consider asking their towns to join CENH as municipal members for $250 a year. I got our Select Board to join CENH this year and we have put this cost into our budget request for next year. This is a very good way to access CENH insights on legislation and other energy policy in New Hampshire. (And you get two tickets to the Local Energy Solutions conference, worth $200!)
Take Action
Join one of the Department of Energy public sessions to make federal funds available for limiting greenhouse emissions. (Details offered above.)
The NH Public Utilities Commission (PUC) will be considering setting a new Net Metering rate for NH residents, business, and local governments. The decision will be issued next May, June, or July. It's a way off. However, the DOE has to develop and submit a position on what that should be by December 1.
Likely, this will be a contentious issue when the case formally begins at the PUC. The DOE/State of NH's position could be a large influence on final order. As you likely know, the Governor has been skeptical of small scale solar throughout his political career. He has shown a willingness to support it on occasion.
Ideally, letters would get to the Governor and/or DOE by Nov 27. In terms of content,
The letters do NOT need to be perfect. It would be better to get more contacts from local governments, energy committees, or businesses than a few immaculate arguments.
Economic arguments (this is good for our taxpayers) may be more influential than environmental arguments (fortunately what's good for the economy/taxpayers is good for GHG emissions.
Ideally individualized copies would be sent to both DOE and Gov.
DOE Commissioner: Jared Chicoine - jared.s.chicoine@energy.nh.gov
Governor: governorsununu@nh.gov
For DOE consider cc'd DOE staff (pick 1?)
DOE DIrector of Regulatory Support: Tom Frantz - Thomas.C.Frantz@energy.nh.gov
Renewable Energy Division: deandra.m.perruccio@energy.nh.gov
General: energy-info@energy.nh.gov
At a Third Act NH virtual event, Kendra Ford of 350NH / NoCoal No Gas encouraged turnout at the Independent System Operator (ISO) New England Customer Liaison Group meeting on December 6th in Boston, beginning at 12 PM. This meeting is open to consumers and others who are interested in the operation of the grid, via either a virtual or a live option. You need to register for the event and there is. (Sign up options are listed above.)
Feed Your Brain
Monadnock monthly newsletter - a model for the future?
https://mailchi.mp/monadnocksustainabilityhub/novement2023?e=3852408a92
The U.S. Armed Forces are tasked with military readiness, not with climate change. So why do they consider climate change a security risk? And what are they doing about it?
Watch the Nov 13 video recording at:
https://sites.google.com/view/new-hampshire-network/events#h.53pimo75iv0q.
Plastics Working Groups minutes.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1WLDb_P6EBOSGPPyx9JWmFxSS_dFiO0vf5yf9kRvbaXU/edit
Update on pollution in the Ammonoosuc River from landfill runoff.
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/RINDGnAGSGY
You'll be interested in what Jackie Augustine has to say about the recent landslide at the Casella-run Ontario County landfill. She's very sharp on political and enviro issues around Geneva, NY. She co-founded a website that allowed people to complain about landfill odors. It marks their location in real time. https://itstinks.org/
On the landslide -- this comes on the one-year anniversary of Casella's $500,000 fine for a host of violations at Ontario Landfill. As Jackie suggests. There's probably much more to this story.
Questions about the Casella disaster from Jon Swan
Maybe that press release was supposed to make it sound like this wasn't a huge issue, but this was a *huge* environmental disaster at the landfill. Maybe you think using the word "disaster" is alarmist or unwarranted, but I'm pretty sure it's spot on. It's not just that over three football fields of soil and trash crashed down like an avalanche on our trash mountain, like "oops...go ahead and put that anywhere," and it's not just that this raises serious concerns about the quality of engineering and environmental oversight that Casella and the county are doing when finishing what is supposed to be a "permanent" solution to a landfill cell. And it's not just that the immediate release of toxic fumes and methane into the air is of serious concern. It's more about the actual physics of the incident. The internal collection and piping structure was, by Casella's own admission, "damaged" and that means (since they are going to put the best possible spin on it) that it was actually *seriously compromised.* It's not just about replacing what was immediately exposed and damaged from the force of the sheering on that side is going to stress the whole system. How do we know that piping on the other side didn't suffer damage from unexpected pressure changes or angular shifts or just physical stress of being connected to a system yanked down the mountain?
How do we trust that the remaining system is reliable and not compromised? And of course, most importantly, at what point in the process is Casella adding the detection odor to the methane transport system? Methane is odorless, but industries have to add odor to it to detect leaks (just like NYSEG does). So is that happening within the landfill collection system itself? Or is it possible that the intense smells people reported Monday night and into Tuesday were for general toxics being released but the magnitude of methane release was even higher?
Who is monitoring air quality downwind? What is the proper radius for notifying households individually and monitoring for adverse health impacts? Where is the list of other landfill gases previously detected and monitored on site that are now potentially released in great magnitude into the atmosphere? Casella isn't going to want to tell you any of this but they are absolutely collecting the data because they are going to sue their contractor (do a quick google search of other landfills that had failed caps and sued their engineering contractors) but they know they could be subject to a suit as well. They are in damage control mode for their business and we need to be in damage control mode for our residents.
At the end of the day, Ontario County has more trash that it can handle, and more trash that Casella can handle. This was not a current deposit zone. This was supposed to represent what *stable*, *long term operations*, what *closure* represents. Their focus and investment is not in getting those things right because the money is in continued operation in current and expanded cells. And who suffers when things go wrong? The unsuspecting residents who have the bad fortune of living in a place where elected officials privilege dollar signs over health and would rather risk long term significant environmental damage and disaster than to shut this operation down.
We need to normalize calling this what it is--an environmental disaster. It's not just an "incident" like someone's gas tank was leaking on the roadway. It was a significant systems failure that caused a major release of toxins and compromised existing safety and operations infrastructure.
The County's press release essentially said "this facility that is really not owned by Casella had an incident caused by a third party contractor that Casella and the DEC are going to figure out, and nothing to see here."
If 3.5 acres of lakefront park fell into the water, we wouldn't call that an "incident"...and that's flat land, not even cubic tons of off-gassing, harmful, toxic waste.
There are so many questions that need immediate, thorough, and direct answers. And until we are convinced that every possible protection measure is being taken and that every health and environmental impact from this disaster is addressed and resolved, we cannot rest.
November 12, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Overview
Perhaps the most important action item available to the Network. Last Thursday Kent Street Coalition offered a two hour webinar on “Untipping the Judiciary.” It included national wide organizations Demand Justice and the American Constitution Society as well as remarks from Andru Volinsky and Cinde Warmington. Their message: Power lays with the federal judges, and they increasing decide elections and the most important cultural issues.
According to the webinar, Donald Trump appointed nearly one quarter of all federal judges, and Biden has done a decent job, but there are many remaining openings. In the last months he has sent only a handful to the Senate which appoints federal judges. The House is not involved. Action is simple. Contact Senators Shaneen and Hassan, and contact them to push forward on as many nominations within the next year.
AND, the next NH governor will select two supreme court judges in 2026
STEERING Committee minutes: Steering Cmte Nov 8, 7 pm
The “overview summary” will appear in your email while the body of the summary will be on the website. Here is the link and scroll down to the most current summary.
https://www.newhampshirenetwork.org/nh-network-news/nh-network-news-updates-2023
Meetings:
Plastics WG Sunday, November 12 6 pm
NH Network monthly meeting Monday, November 13 5 30 pm
Tuesday, November 14 Concord Community Power information session
Wednesday, November 16 Durham Public Library Dr. Dewey speaker
Lebanon Film Series Thursday, November 16 6 pm 8 Billion Angels
Action:
Energy Working Group Update
Bill Mckibben: Stop expansion of LPG exports
Climate Citizen Lobby: Grid and Tax and Dividend legislation
SB 267 a bi-partisen bill Act before November 14th
Contact PUC re: NH Saves before November 19th
Feed Your Brain:
Department of Energy funding opportunities
Casella Applies for new landfill permit
Meetings
Sunday, November 12, 6 pm Plastics WG
We will be joined by Nora Bosworth, Staff Attorney for the Conservation Law Foundation, who will begin guiding us on legislative strategy.
We will also review the 2023-24 Action Steps. If you cannot attend, we would love to know what actions you’re taking - feel free to add any updates to share with the group in the agenda/notes (link above).
Sunday, November 12, 6 pm
ZOOM Link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302:
ID: 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
Monday, November 13 5:30- 7pm NH Network Monthly meeting
Learn why the U.S. Military considers climate change a serious security concern.
From its far-flung bases to its key supply lines and its significant energy consumption, the armed services must make sober and realistic assessments of climate risks.
How are they preparing for these challenges?
~
REGISTER NOW at https://bit.ly/Military_Climate
Tuesday, November 14 6pm
Concord Community Power forum
City Wide Community Center, Canterbury Road
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/3OSAdFpxROE
Wednesday, November 15
In-person, live at Durham Public Library, a presentation from our partners at NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action:
Dr. Robert Dewey is a retired cardiologist from CMC in Manchester, and a Co-Chair of the Speakers' Bureau at NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action. Part of their mission is to educate other healthcare workers and the public about the very serious health effects of climate change, hoping that as people learn about this they will be more willing to advocate for climate solutions. Please take a look at their website: nhclimatehealth.org
Thursday, November 16 6:00 PM
Lebanon film and speaker series Kilton Library Community Room
8 BILLION ANGELS
Are There Too Many Of Us For Planet Earth?
Today, humanity’s demand for resources is vastly outpacing nature’s ability to supply them. Food, water, climate and extinction emergencies are unfolding before our eyes. 8 BILLION ANGELS tells the truth about the conflict between our human numbers and the sustainability of our planet.
The agenda is here - please email chea...@gmail.com with any additions.
Take Action
The Energy Working Group has kicked off,
and there is a small group who will herd cats for the first six months as we decide how we want to focus our energies. We are likely to be meeting once a month on a Thursday at 4:00 - which Thursday TBD. If people want to add their name to the Energy Working Group list serve, they can email Susan Richman (susan7richman@gmail.com). The majority of people joining the first two calls have been members of local Energy Committees/Commissions, and others included elected officials and representatives of non-profit organizations. The two main areas of focus are 1) exchanging practical information about local energy initiatives and 2) engaging on legislation and policy of interest. The first substantive information exchange has been on examples of RFPs for municipal solar projects.
The Energy Working Group portion of the NH Network website is https://www.newhampshirenetwork.org/working-groups/energy, which has meeting minutes and will eventually become a repository of this kind of useful information.
NH Network Energy WG’s google group is https://groups.google.com/g/nh-network-energy-working-group. Members can send emails to nh-network-energy-working-group@googlegroups.com
From Bill McKibben Stop Expansion of LNG Exports
As this hottest year in human history winds towards its close, I’m writing to ask for your help with what may be the single biggest climate fight left on planet Earth. And it’s right here at home.
The US is planning to quadruple the export of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) from the Gulf of Mexico over the next few years—there are plans for 20 huge export terminals to add to the seven that already exist. If they are built, the emissions associated with them will be as large as all the emissions from every home, factory, and car in the EU. The emissions associated with them will wipe out every bit of progress the U.S. has made on reducing carbon and methane since 2005.
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/_NbbTZVk6_Q
Citizens Climate Lobby: Big Wires Act and Carbon Fee and Dividend
Support grid resilience, the next step forward for permitting reform (call Congress about the BIG WIRES Act): citizensclimatelobby.org/get-loud-take-action/big-wires
Support Carbon Fee and Dividend (email your Representative to co-sponsor the Energy Innovation Act): citizensclimatelobby.org/get-loud-take-action/energy-innovation-act
Before Nov 14, email/call NH House Finance Committee- Support SB267
This bill was authored by Sen. Avard, enjoyed bipartisan support, and DES endorsement last spring, but party-line votes cut it off. This bill is a wise use of funds for necessary DES efforts to avoid combined impacts from pollution, called "Cumulative Impacts Analysis" (CIA)
CIA is already adopted in other states, and will help DES to better protect people while industries can better plan permit applications, a costly process.
It will fund a DES staff person to examine DES permitting and find ways to avoid multiple impacts on a community; impacts that would otherwise harm health and economic vigor.
Use the link below to email/call the 22 member committee. (10 Rep, 12 Dem)
The New Hampshire House of Representatives (state.nh.us)
Any questions, please email or call me, Cynthia Walter, Ph.D
412-610-4327
NH Saves and the PUC Please write a letter to the PUC (Public Utilities Commission) ASAP -- but no later than November 19.
To help write your letter, below is information from Cathy Corkery of the NH chapter of Sierra Club, and STE member Representative Rebecca McWilliams. (With the current administration, NH McWilliams: PUC seems opposed to energy efficiency methods (calling it "downshifting of costs," even though a study on the matter determined cost to ratepayers is just pennies each month)
This would overturn legal precedent, settled law of over 20 years.
Sierra Club
NH Saves has over 20 successful years of saving hundreds of millions of dollars in lowering energy bills for residential, commercial, and industrial customers.
The plan up for consideration, 2024-2026, is a continuation of this successful programing in NH that
Effectively adds $2.27 in benefits for every dollar spent;
Supports 1,718 local jobs year round in the state;
Local investments build local economy - unlike fossil fuels that come from outside of the state;
Local government investments lower energy demands in public buildings thus lowering demand on property taxes;
Lower energy demand means less unhealthy pollution - avoidance of 17 tons of SO2 emissions and 175 tons of NOX emissions, both serious and dangerous air pollutants, and 2 Million Tons of CO2.
Submit supportive comments to the NH Public Utility Commission before November 20
NH Saves Comments To: clerks...@puc.nh.gov Subject: Public Comment in Docket 23-068 Dear PUC Clerk, I am writing in support of the NH Saves program in Docket 23-068. Then add your story.
(If you're shy about writing, Sierra Club suggests these prompts: I am/We are... I/We value... But right now... ACTION REQUESTED...)
ENDORSEMENT OF THE PROGRAM by our 4 utility companies!!):
Background
As you may recall the PUC dealt a traumatic blow to the NHSaves efficiency programs in the fall of 2021. This led to the total shutdown of the NH efficiency programs, upending residential, commercial, municipal, and industrial projects while also disrupting the work and incomes of many efficiency companies and their employees. The economic impact was likely very high and the NHSaves programs and the energy-efficiency workforce are still recovering. Another bad PUC order will be even more devastating.
Over the past year, the Chair of the PUC has shown considerable skepticism concerning the value of energy efficiency, and even with two recent bills passed by the legislature to clarify how the EE programs should be valued, there is deep concern that the PUC will issue another harmful order.
In talking with stakeholders, concerns have been raised about how DOE plans to support the NHSaves program at the PUC. At this time, as the utilities continue to restore programs and rebuild faith among their contractors it is imperative that the plan be approved. DOE's strong support will be instrumental in preventing the PUC from making a bad decision.
Feed Your Brain
Funding Notice: DOE Seeks Lead Organizations for Equitable Solar Communities of Practice
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/GZhVLnzhSXk
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Solar Energy Technologies Office, under a Partnership Intermediary Agreement with ENERGYWERX, created the Equitable Solar Communities of Practice program to support the equitable distribution of the benefits of solar.
This opportunity closes on December 8, 2023, at 5 p.m. ET. For more information on this program and to apply, visit the ENERGYWERX Equitable Solar Communities of Practice webpage.
DOE Issues Notice of Intent to Fund Research for Waste-to-Energy Community Solutions that Advance the U.S. Bioeconomy
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/bSMsLMYM5hc
The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Bioenergy Technologies Office (BETO) and Vehicle Technologies Office (VTO) announced their intent to issue a funding opportunity announcement (FOA) to support the development of community planning and strategies for converting organic waste into feedstock for various clean transportation fuel products. The WASTE: Waste Analysis and Strategies for Transportation End-uses funding opportunity would help local communities develop cost-effective approaches to sustainably manage their waste stream infrastructures. It would also help municipalities and local transportation authorities meet local demand for energy that can be derived from these waste streams.
Casella Submits New Landfill Application
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/xvjnYvbbZSo
November 5 , 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Meetings
Wednesday, November 8th 7 pm NH Network Steering Committee, NH Network
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88391481728?pwd=OTlYeGNWb0V4bDgwZXRIY2JlVXU5QT09
Meeting ID: 883 9148 1728
Passcode: 846696
Thursday, November 9th 8:30 to 4 pm NH Energy Symposium
Grappone Conference Center
As we look towards the future, energy infrastructure and sources in New Hampshire will require development and modernization to lower costs and meet the demands of tomorrow with increased electrification on the horizon.
This year's symposium has expert panelists lined up for the following topics:
Online registration closes at noon on Wednesday, November 8. Walk-ins will be allowed based on availability but there is a $25 surcharge and payment is due at the door.
Sunday, November 12, 6 pm Plastics WG
ZOOM Link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302:
ID: 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
Monday, November 13 5:30- 7pm NH Network Monthly meeting
Learn why the U.S. Military considers climate change a serious security concern.
From its far-flung bases to its key supply lines and its significant energy consumption, the armed services must make sober and realistic assessments of climate risks.
How are they preparing for these challenges?
~
REGISTER NOW at https://bit.ly/Military_Climate
Thursday, November 16 6:00 PM Lebanon film and speaker series
Kilton Library Community Room
8 BILLION ANGELS
Are There Too Many Of Us For Planet Earth?
Today, humanity’s demand for resources is vastly outpacing nature’s ability to supply them. Food, water, climate and extinction emergencies are unfolding before our eyes. 8 BILLION ANGELS tells the truth about the conflict between our human numbers and the sustainability of our planet.
8 BILLION ANGELS takes us on an immersive and emotional journey into the lives of farmers, fishermen and others as they confront the economic, social and health effects of unsustainable population growth.
8 BILLION ANGELS offers solutions to our environmental crises that are practical, high-impact, and scientifically proven to heal the planet and ensure a better quality of life for all Earth's inhabitants.
Take Action
Citizens Climate Lobby: Big Wires Act and Carbon Fee and Dividend
Support grid resilience, the next step forward for permitting reform (call Congress about the BIG WIRES Act): citizensclimatelobby.org/get-loud-take-action/big-wires
Support Carbon Fee and Dividend (email your Representative to co-sponsor the Energy Innovation Act): citizensclimatelobby.org/get-loud-take-action/energy-innovation-act
From a Network member:
It would be nice if someone from the NH Network went to the NH Energy Symposium on Thur, Nov 9, 8:30 AM-4 PM, so we'd get an idea of how the BIA is leaning these days. Cost is $150 for non-members/$125 for members. Deadline to sign up is Wed noon. I see Sam Evans-Brown and Don Kreis are on the agenda. It would be nice to know how the BIA, Michael Vose and Marc Brown, etc. are viewing "sustainability" these days.
Feed Your Brain
Please do not hesitate to reach out if Senator Shaheen can be helpful to you and your community or organization.
Senator Shaheen Updates:
Senator Shaheen recently became Chair of the Senate Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee. Senator Shaheen’s first hearing will be tomorrow, Wednesday, November 1 at 2:30 on the topic of “The Great Outdoors: Small Businesses and America’s Outdoor Recreation Economy.” New Hampshire Small Business Owner, Andrew Drummond of Ski the Whites will be one of the witnesses for the hearing. The hearing will be livestreamed on the Senate Small Business and Entrepreneurship Committee website.
NH Municipal Association and Senator Shaheen’s office held a webinar about Elective Pay, a provision of Inflation Reduction Act. Elective pay allows applicable entities, including tax-exempt and governmental entities that would otherwise be unable to claim certain credits because they do not owe federal income tax, to benefit from some clean energy tax credits. By choosing this election, the amount of the credit is treated as a payment of tax and any overpayment will result in a refund. You can re-watch the webinar and access further resources about elective pay here.
New Hampshire Congressional Delegation Applauds Twin States Clean Energy Link’s Selection to be Part of $1.3 Billion U.S. Department of Energy Program.
Senator Shaheen celebrated the towns of Exeter, Peterborough and Harrisville that were among only 12 projects nationwide selected for $900,000 through the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant (EECBG) Program. Senator Shaheen was in Exeter to discuss their project which will partner with NHSaves and Weatherization programs in the state to bring energy efficient upgrades to over 100 manufactured homes.
Clean Energy NH was awarded $500,000 through USDA RD, Rural Energy for America Program (REAP) Technical Assistance funding that was expanded through the Inflation Reduction Act.
U.S. Senator Jeanne Shaheen, a senior member of the U.S. Senate Appropriations Subcommittee that funds the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP), announced with the NH delegation that $27.6 million in LIHEAP funds are being awarded to New Hampshire to assist Granite State families ahead of the winter season with fuel assistance. Granite Staters can apply for heating assistance through their local Community Action Partnership office. Please visit CAPNH.org to find an office near you.
U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Institute of Food and Agriculture (NIFA) announced an investment of nearly $3.4 Million in New Technologies for Ag Extension at the University of New Hampshire.
New Hampshire will receive a Department of Energy (DOE) award totaling $6,619,797 to help modernize the state’s power grid. The funding will be used to invest in disadvantaged communities, bolster grid resilience for extreme weather and other disruptive events and provide additional workforce development and training opportunities. New Hampshire will hold a competitive selection process to identify projects in need of this funding. These grants were funded by the Bipartisan Infrastructure Law.
U.S. Senators Jeanne Shaheen and Susan Collins announced their bipartisan resolution to designate October 4, 2023, as “Energy Efficiency Day” passed the Senate unanimously. The resolution celebrates and promotes the economic and environmental benefits gained from investing in energy efficiency.
Below are a couple of grants and programs that were announced last month. Please reach out if Senator Shaheen can be helpful in identifying grants or writing a letter of support for a federal grant.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced the availability of $235 million in grants to assess and clean up polluted brownfield sites across the country. The new grants through EPA’s Brownfields Multipurpose, Assessment, and Cleanup (MAC) program will advance environmental justice and help transform what were once polluted, vacant, and abandoned properties into community assets while spurring economic revitalization in underserved communities.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service is making nearly $50 million in grant funding available for proposals that support crucial links between resilient, healthy forests, strong rural economies and jobs in the forestry sector. The open funding opportunity comes through the Forest Service’s three key grant programs to support the forest products economy: Wood Innovations Grant, Community Wood Grant, and Wood Products Infrastructure Assistance Grant Programs. The agency is seeking proposals that support innovative uses of wood in the construction of low carbon buildings, as a renewable energy source, and in manufacturing and processing products. These programs also provide direct support to expand and retrofit wood energy systems and wood products manufacturing facilities nationwide.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service announced the availability of up to $36 million through President Biden’s Investing in America agenda for fish passage projects across the nation that address outdated, unsafe or obsolete dams, culverts, levees and other barriers fragmenting our nation’s rivers and streams.
FEMA is making $1.8 billion available for two grant programs designed to help communities increase their resilience to the impacts of climate change, including increasingly frequent and extreme weather events. The Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC) annual grant program is making $1 billion available for projects that protect people and infrastructure from natural hazards and the effects of climate change. The Flood Mitigation Assistance program is making $800 million available for projects that mitigate flood risks facing homes and communities across the nation.
A report on Chemical Cycling: What It Does and Does Not Do
…But a new report from the nonprofits Beyond Plastics and the International Pollutants Elimination Network, or IPEN, says chemical recycling is a “dangerous deception” that will only exacerbate pollution and environmental injustice while failing to address the plastics crisis.
“The landscape of chemical recycling is littered with pollution and failure,” and relying on it is an “unreliable and polluting approach” to resolve the global plastics crisis, Jennifer Congdon, Beyond Plastics’ deputy director, told journalists at a press conference on Tuesday. She and the report co-authors called on President Joe Biden to place a national moratorium on new chemical recycling operations in the U.S. and urged international negotiators to disavow the process as part of the global plastics treaty that will be discussed during a third round of negotiations in Nairobi later this month.
Read More: https://gizmodo.com/a-report-calls-chemical-recycling-a-dangerous-deceptio-1850989026
Advocates fear N.H. clean energy proposal would pit nuclear against solar, wind
If not designed carefully, critics say a clean energy standard that includes nuclear power could undercut the market for renewable energy credits.
Climate and clean energy advocates in New Hampshire say a pending proposal to define nuclear power as clean energy could undercut solar and wind power in the state.
Though the details are still in the works, state Rep. Michael Vose, chair of the legislature’s science, technology, and energy committee, is drafting a bill that would allow nuclear power generators, such as New Hampshire’s Seabrook Station, to receive payments for contributing clean energy to the grid.
October 30, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
What’s Happening at the NH Network!
Our Calendar with NH Network’s and Partners’ Events
Table of Contents
- Meetings
Climate Citizens WG 11/1, Local Energy Solutions Annual Conference 11/2, Energy WG 11/3, NH Association of Conservation Commissions Annual Conference 11/04, Citizens Climate Fall Conference 11/04, Sierra Club 11/9, Plastics WG 11/12, NH Network Monthly Webinar - Climate and Military Security 11/13
- Take Action
Support the initiative to educate your local representative on climate science - intervention needed!
Support limiting waste on political signage for the 2024 elections
- Feed Your Brain
Future Crunch Weekly Update: GLOBAL GOOD NEWS
NH Network Steering Committee minutes
Plastic Working Group minutes
Meetings
Wednesday, November 1 — 7:00 pm Climate Working Group
https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz0 -
Thursday, November 2 — 8 am to 4 pm 2023 Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference
The annual Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference is New Hampshire's premier event for local energy champions, policymakers, municipal officials, town staff, regulators, and industry representatives.
https://www.cleanenergynh.org/event-details/2023-local-energy-solutions-les-conference
Organized by Clean Energy NH, the Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference is the state's premier energy conference and the only event of its kind that brings together the clean energy community in New Hampshire. Collectively we learn about the latest topics, listen to experts discuss innovative ideas and best practices, and experience new technologies first-hand. The LES Conference offers best of the best networking opportunities with industry partners, state policy professionals, non-profits, and municipal leaders.
Friday, November 3, 2023 — 2:30 PM Energy Working Group Meeting #2
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/81153137271?pwd=UWpkK3cxTnBmOUdZZzFVVXZrSzlBQT09
Meeting ID: 811 5313 7271
Passcode: 729616
Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kcf85L6UYD
Saturday, November 4 NH Association of Conservation Commissions Annual Conference
https://www.nhacc.org/annualmeeting
Saturday, November 4 CCL's Fall Virtual Conference, Grassroots Rising: Leveling Up in the Climate Fight -
https://citizensclimatelobby.org/climate-change-conferences/fall/
November 9 Sierra Club monthly meeting
https://www.mobilize.us/climateactionnh/event/584089/
Sunday, November 12 — 6 pm Plastics Working Group
ZOOM Link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302:
ID: 627 560 9302
One tap mobile
+13092053325, 6275609302# US
We will be joined by Nora Bosworth, Staff Attorney for the Conservation Law Foundation, who will begin guiding us on legislative strategy.
Monday, November 13 — 5:30- 7pm NH Network Monthly meeting
Learn why the U.S. Military considers climate change a serious security concern.
From its far-flung bases to its key supply lines and its significant energy consumption, the armed services
must make sober and realistic assessments of climate risks.
How are they preparing for these challenges?
~
REGISTER NOW at https://bit.ly/Military_Climate
Take Action
From John Gage:
Thank you for the kind feedback about my Climate Science Intervention article. I've been asked for details regarding what we can do about this together. Here are two ideas:
Contact your State Reps to tell them you read the article "NH House Needs a Climate Science Intervention" in the Concord Monitor, and you want them to contact the House Science, Technology, and Energy Committee Chairman, Rep. Michael Vose, to encourage him to hold an information-gathering hearing with the state's climate science and policy experts. State experts include our State's Climatologist (Dr. Mary Stampone of UNH, who participated in an NH Network event last year at https://www.newhampshirenetwork.org/events#h.nnhbimu0a69j), Dr. Cameron Wake of UNH, NH DES staff, and economists at UNH and Dartmouth (such as Dr. Charles Wheelan, who participated in an NH Network event last year starting at 44:15 at https://www.newhampshirenetwork.org/events#h.nnhbimu0a69j).
You can find your Reps' email addresses at https://www.gencourt.state.nh.us/house/members/. Find them one by one in the "Select a Member" Roster list, or download the whole roster in a form you can load in a spreadsheet (e.g., Google Sheets will load the Microsoft 2003 version), sort by town, and you'll have easy access to all the phone numbers and email addresses.Join the November NH Network Climate Working Group meeting on Wednesday, November 1, at 7:00 pm on Zoom, to brainstorm more actions. A preliminary agenda and the connection information are here. We hope individuals and a representative from every NH Network member organization that works on climate change will attend and bring their topics to discuss. Email me if you want to add an item to the agenda.
And one final request: please register for the Citizens' Climate Lobby Fall Conference. This free, Zoom-based climate solutions conference on November 4 will bring you up to speed on climate legislative prospects in Congress, and you'll hear experts advising how citizens can have maximum impact. In addition to all the good work you do individually and at the community and state levels, addressing climate pollution enough to hold warming below 1.5˚C requires much stronger federal policies that reach beyond our borders. CCL exists to help citizens contribute effectively to help make that happen. If you are new to CCL, I recommend starting with CCL's Informational Session at noon at the Conference Day. You can register at citizensclimatelobby.org/climate-change-conferences/fall/.
From Peggy Longley:
Important LOCAL initiative on limiting plastic use for political signage.
1. I would like to see political organizations investing in more recyclable the Poly(ethelene)-bag signs that stretch over a metal frame and are recyclable through Nex-trex deposit bins*
Vs Corrugated plastic type (sturdier, slightly more expensive BUT have to go in landfill. Someone sugged NH ) but let's choose the more sustainable sign! Let's see how it goes!
Of course both signs come with metal frames/supports which can be reused or recycled.
2. Most all signage companies offer both types of signs so there should be no problem finding the Ply-bags. It is the same material as the plastic mailers we receive through the mail.
3. Retailers** in NH that have Nex Trex bins for 'film' (poly-bag) plastic. Signs can just be rolled up and placed in bins after campaign & election season:
DeMoulas Market Basket
Hannaford
Whole Foods
Shaw's
Kohl's
Ocean State Job Lot
and Town of Littleton and many, many other towns.
4. Mission and Goal:
I will contact the Dem Party Headquarters this week to obtain county headquarter (includ. Republican) contact info.
I will create a link to a poster that would have everything a party headquarters forward to their candidates.
I will let NH Network & PWG members who are interested, know how they can help by sending this email with link out to candidates in their county. It will have all information to help candidates make a choice for recyclability for their political lawn signs and banners...AND where the plastic can be taken to be recycled after use (above list).
Time frame to be established.
This might be more info than you're looking for. Please know if I can help further.
Feed Your Brain
FUTURE CRUNCH WEEKLY UPDATE - ALL GOOD NEWS
NH Network Steering Committee meeting notes:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1yailSjZWHQJnDWYnd29hKG-MkhXhO4PpoQvfsS-rOQg/edit
Plastics WG meeting notes:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1vtseT5p7iVEYdKq_bPFWMutT1ezvG9KIEfynnE8Za_s/edit
The EU is fighting microplastics pollution with a ban on products that have microplastics added to them, including cosmetics, detergents, glitter, fertilisers, toys, and artificial sports surfaces. An estimated 42,000 tons of microplastics are added to products sold in the EU every year. 'This is an opportunity for the European industry to be at the forefront of the development towards more sustainability and innovation.' DW
Between 2018 and 2022, Indonesia reduced its marine plastic waste from 615,675 tonnes to 408,885. This means the country’s position among the world’s largest contributors of plastic waste has fallen from second to fifth, a trend that looks set to continue as it aims for a further 70% reduction of marine debris by 2024. Antara News
October 22, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
What’s Happening at the NH Network
Our Calendar with NH Network’s and Partners’ Events
Overview
Minutes:
Initial meeting of the Energy WG Minutes ENERGY GROUP Oct 19, 2024
NH Network Climate WG NH Network Climate Working Group - Monthly Meeting Agenda /
Plastics WG Meeting Notes #52 - October 15, 2023
Meetings:
Inflation Reduction Act, NH Network Steering Committee, Dover Plastic Reduction Group webinar on EPR, Plastics WG, Climate WG. Local Energy Solutions Conference (LES), NH Food Alliance Cafe Series, North Country Food and Agricultural Summit
Take Action:
Submit testimony on the 2024-26 Triennial Energy Efficiency Plan
Submit testimony on the 10 year Transportation Bill.
Plastics WG Mesh Bag project
Submit testimony on solid waste expansion
Feed Your Brain:
Forever Chemicals Are Eternal No More Thanks To Pollution Destroying…..
NH House Needs a Climate Science Intervention (John Gage)
NH Food Alliance Series
Great Green Wall - film opportunity in Portsmouth Public Library October 26
NY Times: In a Twist, Old Coal Plants can Deliver Renewable Energy
Access to Natural Gas Keeps Our Lights On (Michael Vose, Chair STE Committee)
NH Energy and Action Education program: school curriculum for clean energy
Meetings
Monday, October 23 11 am
Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) Elective Pay Webinar. Those working with nonprofits, churches, schools, municipalities and others that are tax-exempt and wish to consider pursuing upcoming opportunities to reduce energy efficiency, electrification or renewable energy project costs may wish to attend this webinar, and how it may be helpful to your town or non-profit
Monday, Oct 23, 2023 05:00 PM NH NETWORK Steering Committee Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83830125629?pwd=bVZQVlowWDVlbm0wdFc2YjdtdnlKUT09
MINUTES from Last Steering Committee available at:
Minutes, Steering Committee, 10/18/2023
Thursday, October 26 7 pm Dover Plastic Reduction Group.
Guest speaker Peter Blair, Policy and Advocacy Director at Just Zero, a national non-profit advancing community-centered Zero Waste solutions. Peter will present information on Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), a policy approach that holds manufacturers responsible for the lifecycle of their products including handling the waste produced. Just Zero craft a model bill that we expect to be used as the foundation for a NH bill. On Monday of this week, the NH House EPR Study Committee voted to send forward proposed EPR legislation to be considered during the next legislative session, so this is a particularly timely topic. To obtain the zoom link, respond to Kristine’s Baber’s email https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox/FMfcgzGwHLjpVJtNfVdHLKRJwzclsnGV
Sunday, October 29 6 pm Plastics WG
(Also, stop by the Mesh Bag Mamas Produce Bag Launch on Saturday, October 21, Noon - 2 pm to cheer us on. Photos of Mesh Bag Mamas in action attached, along with educational with postcard insert. To start your own Mesh Bag Mamas project to help raise awareness about reusables contact chea...@gmail.com.)
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
Wednesday, November 1 at 7:00 pm Climate WG
https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz0 -
NH Network Climate Working Group - Monthly Meeting Agenda / Minutes
Thursday, November 2 8 am to 4 pm 2023 Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference The annual Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference is New Hampshire's premier event for local energy champions, policymakers, municipal officials, town staff, regulators, and industry representatives.
https://www.cleanenergynh.org/event-details/2023-local-energy-solutions-les-conference
WHAT IS LES?
Organized by Clean Energy NH, the Local Energy Solutions (LES) Conference is the state's premier energy conference and the only event of its kind that brings together the clean energy community in New Hampshire. Collectively we learn about the latest topics, listen to experts discuss innovative ideas and best practices, and experience new technologies first-hand. The LES Conference offers best of the best networking opportunities with industry partners, state policy professionals, non-profits, and municipal leaders.
November 3 noon to 1 pm The NH Food Alliance’s 2023-2024 Network Café Series
is exploring A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience, a four-volume report of foundational food system data commissioned and released by the New England State Food System Planners Partnership. The New England State Food System Planners Partnership is a collaboration among six state-level food system organizations and Food Solutions New England.
Register: https://www.nhfoodalliance.org/get-involved/network-cafe-series
November 8th 2nd Annual North Country Food and Agriculture Summit is now open!
Please register today. Registration is open until November 1st. Share this invitation with your networks, friends, and co-workers.
Take Action
Don Kreis, NH Consumer Advocate, expressed his strong support of continuing NH Saves. The PUC has hearings Oct 25 & 31 on the upcoming triennial energy efficiency plan for 2024, 2025, and 2026. and hearings that are coming before the PUC on Oct. 25 and 31.
Please write to p...@puc.nh.gov, mention docket DE 23-068 in the subject line, and ask the PUC to approve the 2024-2026 triennial energy efficiency plan. The PUC must decide by 11/30.
TALKING POINTS: businesses and households alike need to plan their budgets, and a 3-year horizon is especially needful for business, as they decide major energy expenditures.
When the last 3-year energy plan tottered, a swath of NH energy contractors lost business or went out of business.
Transportation - comments due Oct 26.
At the meeting I attended, it seemed clear that priorities are road upgrade and enlargement, bridge repair, and airports. Please write to urge development of PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION OPTIONS.
Your input wanted -- transportation in NH
Hearings are happening now for the Draft 2025-2034 Ten Year Transportation Plan.
The hearings began 9/7 but continue to 10/25. Here is the link to view the schedule:
https://mm.nh.gov/files/uploads/dot/remote-docs/final-gacit-schedule.pdf
Written input additionally accepted, through Nov 3, directed to William.e.watsonjr@dot.nh.gov
and there is a survey to fill out at https://metroquestsurvey.com/yn8w8t (The survey is tilted toward road construction & improvement – but there are open comment opportunities.)
there's a survey for the 10 year plan: https://live.metroquestsurvey.com/?u=yn8w8t#!/?p=web&pm=dynamic&s=1&popup=WTD
HOWEVER: The survey gives you a very narrow range of choices, mostly to do with road & bridge upgrade and road expansion. You have to creatively use the few open-ended spaces if you want to urge more public transportation, EV charging etc.
Sample letter:
To the Commissioner of NHDOT and the Executive Councilors,
The ten year plan for transportation in NH lacks the imagination and forward look that is required to address the challenges of efficiently moving people and goods in New Hampshire in the coming decade. While it focuses on improving our roads and bridges, the plan lacks investments in electric vehicle charging infrastructure and public transportation. We need our transportation plan to carry New Hampshire into a future where vehicles will be electrified and fast trains will carry people and goods around the state and connect with economic centers, especially to the south of us. People in NH have been asking for the commuter rail from Boston to extend to Nashua and Manchester for years. Now is the time to make it happen.
Every car manufacturer has recognized that electric transportation will replace gasoline vehicles over the next twenty years with benefits in lower emissions and reduced operating costs for state residents. In order to make that happen, it is the responsibility of public officials to establish policy and economic support to make more fast chargers available in the state through a public-private partnership with the electric industry. The State can lead the way by transitioning governmental vehicle fleets to significantly increase electric vehicle use.
Our transportation system is at a crossroads. I encourage you to look forward, not backwards and provide funding for public transportation and electrification infrastructure so that New Hampshire can continue to be the great place we all love even as the world spins unpredictably around us.
From Cindy Heath/Plastics WG
Notes from tonight here. This is an amazing group of activists. Thank you all for getting it done in your communities and statewide.
We welcome updates from members in the updates section of the notes. Feel free to drop a line about what actions you’re taking these days.
Great investigative reporting article on the nefarious practices of chemical recycling companies, Garbage In, Toxics Out (The Intercept 9.28.23)
Stop by the Mesh Bag Mamas Produce Bag Launch on Saturday, October 21, Noon - 2 pm to cheer us on. Photos of Mesh Bag Mamas in action attached, along with educational with postcard insert. To start your own Mesh Bag Mamas project to help raise awareness about reusables contact chea...@gmail.com.
From Jon Swan. He highlights these are his opinions and for his complete summary click on this email link. https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/#inbox/FMfcgzGwHLkxFBZFPCzJFggKwNSKvgSG
Here is part of his email:
I just wanted to share some updates, and of course, documents. There is SO MUCH going on, but I will try to summarize and be as brief as possible. I apologize for the attachments, but hopefully they are of interest and are informative.
First off, I have been spending a lot of time in Concord at NHDES, as a result of a 91-A Right-To-Know request for files relative to the NCES Landfill and my research into the explanations offered by Casella/Sanborn Head/NHDES for the numerous detections of PFAS and other contaminants at the numerous groundwater monitoring wells that lie outside of the lined landfill, located within the watershed and upgradient of the Ammonoosuc River. I have had an op-ed relative to my findings printed in both the Concord Monitor and the Union Leader, attached, and linked below. I do hope the powers that be have read my op-ed, and subsequently, Dr. Adam Finkel's, as it is my firm belief that the landfill is failing. I continue to amass documentation that supports my conclusion that NCES is failing, primarily due to the Stage I and possibly Stage II liner systems. The construction reports and NHDES responses make for some revealing reading!
Jon Swan op-ed, with links:
Dr. Adam Finkel op-ed, with links:
If you have not yet, please, take a moment and reach out to our elected officials and ask them to intervene at NCES. It's time to stop feeding the source of the contaminants which are being released within the watershed of the Ammonoosuc River. Garbage going into the landfill leads to more leachate generation, which is not being contained within the landfill. It's time to close the NCES Landfill in Bethlehem and address the contamination which is being released within the watershed of the Ammonoosuc River.
Contact Senator Jeanne Shaheen: https://www.shaheen.senate.gov/contact/contact-jeanne
Contact Senator Maggie Hassan: https://www.hassan.senate.gov/contact/email
Contact Congresswoman Anne Kuster: https://kuster.house.gov/contact/
You can also send an email to the aides of Senator Shaheen, Senator Hassan, and Congresswoman Kuster:
chuck_henderson@shaheen.senate.gov
ben_belanger@hassan.senate.gov
stephanie.weiner@mail.house.gov
Feed Your Brain
Forever Chemicals Are Eternal No More Thanks To Pollution Destroying…..
NH Food Alliance
Thank you to those who attended our October Network Café, part of our 2023-2024 Network Café Series on Friday, October 6. For those who missed our October Café, we were joined by Brian Donohue, of Brandeis University, the lead researcher for the team whose research became “Volume 1: Estimating Resilient Eating Patterns” of A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience. Brian shared what the team learned in analyzing dietary patterns across major food groups to understand the food that New Englanders currently consume and how that might change by 2030, followed by a discussion of the research’s implications for New Hampshire's food system.
What would it take for 30% of the food consumed in New England to be regionally produced by 2030? Join the NH Food Alliance network as we address this question during our 2023-2024 Network Café Series through A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience, a four-volume report of foundational food system data commissioned and released by the New England State Food System Planners Partnership. The report lays out an unprecedented compilation of the most current New England food systems data and frames the data intentionally to inspire conversation and action towards New England producing and consuming more of its own food.
During each Network Café, the lead researcher for each volume of A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience will join us to dig into the data. They will provide a short summary of the volume and answer questions, helping our network of partners utilize the report in strategic planning, fundraising, advocacy, and other work as we continue to build vibrant food systems in New Hampshire and New England.
The New England State Food System Planners Partnership is a collaboration among six state-level food system organizations and Food Solutions New England. Please note that our September Network Café will be held on the second Friday of the month to avoid the Labor Day holiday weekend. If you have questions about our 2023-2024 Network Café Series, reach out to our Communications Coordinator, Colleen Stewart, HERE
From John Gage NH Network Climate WG:
NH House Needs a Climate Science Intervention
When my daughter and I attended a hearing of the NH House Committee on State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs last year, I was astonished by the disinformation we heard in the testimony of two House Science, Technology, and Energy (STE) Committee members. In support of a House resolution that called for ignoring mainstream science and economics, they repeated long-disproven climate myths promoted by fossil fuel industry-funded front groups. My daughter had refuted the fallacies in a Concord Monitor article before the hearing (My Turn: NH Legislature attempts to remove our best climate solution). No citizens testified in support of the resolution, five testified in opposition to it, and it was overwhelmingly opposed in online testimony (149 to 4). Yet the committee took the two STE members' opinions over the public input and voted HR 17 ought to pass down party lines. The resolution later passed in a House floor vote with only Republican support.
It is the responsibility of STE Committee members to advise all House committees on scientific matters. To establish her credibility, one of the HR 17 co-sponsors noted that she had been an STE committee member for four legislative sessions. But her testimony led me to wonder – where did these crazy ideas come from? Climate science denial and the “free market fundamentalist” ideology have long been refuted by experts in science and economics. Global warming is happening, mainly due to fossil fuel pollution, and policy changes are required to address the market’s failure to account for the costs of that pollution in the price of fossil fuels. It should not be free to pollute. Experts recommend charging the fossil fuel industry a carbon polluters fee to reduce the pollution and giving the money collected to everyone equally to protect household purchasing power. Most families would get more money back than they would spend in trickle-down higher costs. This is the kind of solution HR 17 resolved NOT to do.
What do we tell our children – students who get top marks in science classes and are concerned about climate pollution – when House STE Committee members disregard mainstream science and our state’s own experts? Adding insult to injury, the other STE member called those who disagreed with his opinion “environmental crusaders” three times in his testimony – while my daughter and I waited to share what we knew about climate science from NASA, NOAA, and UNH, and climate policy from our state’s economic experts.
HR 17 was not a sensible, conservative resolution. It was a Koch-inspired statement designed to delay legislation to address Koch Industries' pollution.
Charles Koch accrued his wealth from fossil fuel businesses. The Koch Network is a group of billionaires who fund out-of-state polluter-friendly legislative initiatives via dozens of front groups, including DonorsTrust, Americans for Prosperity, Heartland Institute, American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), and the State Policy Network (of which the Josiah Bartlett Center is the New Hampshire node and the DonorsTrust “dark-money ATM” a heavy funder). These groups produce and promote disinformation about what we know through science, push polluting industries' policies, and delay energy efficiency, electrification, and clean energy progress across the country. They have power in the Concord State House, but they don’t represent New Hampshire businesses, citizens, or our children’s interests.
The Koch infiltration runs high and deep in New Hampshire. Governor Chris Sununu’s connection to the Josiah Bartlett Center goes back to his father, John Sununu, emeritus board member. His brother James is also on the board. One of the STE committee members who sponsored and testified for HR 17, NH House Republican Whip Jeanine Notter, has attended Heartland, ALEC, and similar groups’ conferences in California, Texas, and Florida on all-expenses-paid trips courtesy of Koch-funded front groups valued over $11,500 in the last five years. She distributes their pamphlets and pushes their polluter priorities in legislation. State Legislators’ mailboxes are periodically stuffed with Koch front-group propaganda pushing climate opinions not supported by any scientific organization.
When New Hampshire leaders are guided by out-of-state fossil fuel industry-funded groups rather than by Climate Assessment Reports from our state's official climatologist and information from the NH Department of Environmental Services (des.nh.gov/climate-and-sustainability/climate-change), New Hampshire citizens pay the consequences. Our state lags behind our neighbors in solar installations, EV adoption, charging station deployments, and energy efficiency. We suffered far more than our neighbors when gas, oil, and electricity prices shot up due to the recent Saudi market manipulation and boycott of Russian gas.
How can we demonstrate to our children that our democratic system works for us? We must help our state leaders break their blind allegiance to out-of-state fossil fuel industry interests. The NH House STE Committee leadership needs a climate science intervention.
The Chairman of the STE Committee, Representative Michael Vose of Epping, can not be pleased when two of his committee members promote climate science misinformation as representatives of his committee. He should invite state climate science and economic experts to an STE committee Q&A hearing to clear up their confusion. None of the Democrats on the STE committee suffer from those delusions. But until something changes, the STE Republican majority will continue leading the NH Legislature astray on climate and energy policy, misguided by ideology and out-of-state polluters’ interests.
The first step to addressing a problem is admitting you have one. There are beneficial bipartisan solutions such as Carbon Fee and Dividend, and our state should use them to prepare for major global policy and climate changes that are headed our way.
We wanted to make sure you were aware of our upcoming documentary film screening and community conversation, scheduled for next Tuesday, October 24th. WACNH will screen the film "The Great Green Wall", which follows the journey of Malian Musician, Inna Modja, as she travels the length of this ambitious continent-wide project to prevent the further desertification of the Sahel region. By creating a 9 mile wide living barrier, communities from Senegal to Djibouti are banding together to protect their lands and continue the fight against climate change.
After the film, the audience will break into facilitator lead conversations to further understanding of the themes of the film. These will be lead by community leaders from Education for All Children, Rain for the Sahel and Sahara, and the League of Conservation Voters.
Join us at 6:00 pm on October 24th at the Portsmouth Public Library for this free community event. Advanced registration is requested, as space is limited.
From Catherine Corkery/Sierra Club:
I wanted to share this oped from the Republican State House Committee Chair, Michael Vose, about the necessity of natural gas.
While it has some misinformation and stretches the truth, it is instructional. My hope is to replace the power plants on these industrial sites with clean energy, like solar and battery storage. I attached the recent NYT article on projects just like that. This is the clean energy future we could replicate in NH!!
NY Times: In a Twist, Old Coal Plants can Deliver Renewable Energy
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/15/climate/coal-plants-renewable-energy.html
NH Union Leader – October 17, 2023
Access to natural gas keeps our lights on
Rep. Michael Vose
PROPANE and natural gas get a bad rap. Together, they heat 39% of Granite State homes. Both burn far cleaner than conventional heating fuels, which lowers heating system maintenance costs and reduces carbon emissions. The 60% fewer emissions from natural gas also make it far better than oil and coal for generating electricity. With these positive attributes, what gives gas a sour smell? Critics rail against it for not being renewable (even though renewable gas exists) and for being in high demand worldwide, leading to periods of price volatility. Add to that the possibility that pipelines may become a stranded
cost in a future clean energy grid and natural gas comes out looking like a loser.
But far from being a loser, natural gas has allowed the U.S. to lower its emissions more than any other region over the past 15 years, including the European Union. It has helped keep per capita emissions in the Granite State lower than most other states in the country even though we heat 42% of our homes with fuel oil and kerosene. Replacing coal and oil with gas in the generation of electricity has not just lowered emissions nationally but also lowered its cost. Except in New England. The Northeast has the country’s highest electricity costs due to a shortage of natural gas during periods of peak demand.
Getting this high-value fuel to our borders remains difficult due to limited pipeline capacity. Vast reserves of natural gas reside just a couple of hundred miles to our west. But states like New York discourage building pipelines that cross their borders.
Pipelines symbolize our industrialized past in a gleaming modern world. Even though they lie invisible, buried alongside our highways and beneath our city streets, evidenced only by the occasional compressor station, they inspire an intense notin- my-backyard (NIMBY) response from some citizens and localities. These attitudes have consequences. Last winter saw New England burning oil to make 30% to 40% of its electricity during multiple cold snaps that drew away natural gas to heat homes and businesses. There was simply not enough gas to do both. The region also had to depend on its last remaining coal plant during those periods, increasing both emissions and costs.
Such events will only increase in the winters ahead should natural gas generation continue to be subject to fuel scarcity. A recent bid to the regional grid operator by the coal plant in Bow was not low enough to qualify for ISO-NE capacity payments in 2026, which likely means it will shutter its doors soon. Equally troubling, the Mystic Station natural gas plant near Boston has signaled that it plans to close at the end of 2024. Since the plant uses liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Trinidad/ Tobago delivered to the nearby Everett LNG terminal, a shutdown would likely force the closure of that LNG port. This LNG helps support the pressure in the gas pipeline that runs from Boston to the Canadian eastern provinces and its loss could further reduce gas supply from the north.
In a region that needs more natural gas electricity generation, plant closures can only mean trouble. The region came close to rolling blackouts this past winter and will be even more vulnerable if gas supplies get even tighter. Help surfaced recently with news that Enbridge, the owner of the Algonquin natural gas pipeline, has announced an expansion effort it calls Project Maple. This expansion will replace existing smaller diameter pipe with larger-diameter pipe, increasing total capacity by 25%. While it will not be complete until 2029, Project Maple’s design will allow more natural gas from the plentiful
Utica/Marcellus shale deposits in New York and Pennsylvania to reach New England.
Our regional dependence on natural gas for generating electricity stems in part from the need toprovide reliable backup for renewable energy, which operates intermittently. Gas-fired plants can ramp up and down quickly to provide power when the sun goes down and winds subside. Such ramping guarantees that the lights always come on when you flick the switch. People rely on that dependable power. As the parade of presidential candidates marches through New Hampshire this fall, they need to outline how they will address our nation’s energy future. Natural gas has been a boon to the nation in
the past decade and can serve us well in the decades to come.
Rep. Michael Vose (R-Epping) serves as chairman of the House Science, Technology, and Energy Committee.
From NH Energy Education and Action Program (Aubrey Nelson www.nheep.org 603.493.7225)
We are keen to continue to bring energy and climate learning and awareness of green energy careers into classrooms across the state, and we've also started offering programs for adults and families by partnering with community groups, so we’d love for the opportunity to collaborate with you!
NHEEP has traditionally offered hands-on, engaging, NGSS-aligned programs to support energy and climate science/technical learning for students and teachers. Our programs come in a variety of formats:
Hands-on curricular resource and equipment kits (which you can borrow for no or low-cost).
Co-taught workshops (including, but not limited to Green Energy Careers, Electricity & the Environment and Heat Transfer, all of which are free)
Professional development for teachers (there are several free NGSS Toolkit trainings coming up in November in Manchester, Plymouth or online, and these are also free for educators)
Support for teachers and students interested in planning and implementing energy action projects.
High school team action support: Youth Climate Leader’s Academy, which is an engaging year long program to support high school student teams in planning and implementing action projects.
You can visit our website to learn more about our offerings, or call or email me directly. Several of our equipment kits and our co-taught workshops are free thanks to our partnership with NHSaves, so we can discuss what makes the most sense!
October 15, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Overview - What’s Happening at the NH Network!
Meetings
Plastics WG (tonight), NH Businesses for Social Responsibility series, NH Healthcare Climate Action dinner, Bird Dog training, 2nd Annual North Country Food Summit.
Thursday, 10/19 at 6pm, will be the initial meeting of an Energy Group bringing together members of statewide Energy Committees and individuals hoping to influence NH's energy future.
Take Action
Study Extended Producer Responsibility Monday, Oct.16 starting at 10:00 AM -
watch and/or submit testimony.
Submit testimony on the 10 year Transportation Bill.
Feed Your Brain
Duplicity of corporations about their efforts at sustainability
NH Energy Educator and Action Offers educational, career and resource programs for Schools. Editorial:
E Waste Anxiety is not warranted.
Editorial: Why NCES Landfill is Failing.
More From Us and Our Partners
New Hampshire Businesses for Social Responsibility
Find out more and register for this free program which just launched today and runs through December 8th ... www.nhbsr.org/climate
Meetings
October 15 6 pm Plastics Working Group. Rev. Rob Grabill (UCC @ Dartmouth) will provide an update on UCC plastic reduction efforts
Join Zoom Meeting https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
October 18 5 to 8 pm NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action in person dinner and meeting.
Join us to celebrate the accomplishments of the organization over the past year, and hold a strategic planning session for our future.
Healthcare website https://www.nhclimatehealth.org/our-events (Numerous other events are offered.)
Thursday, 10/19 at 6pm, will be the initial meeting of an Energy Group bringing together members of statewide Energy Committees and individuals hoping to influence NH's energy future. Concerns you have voiced so far include:
availability of funding for projects in your towns and sharing the effort of finding & applying,
supporting greater energy efficiency measures,
status of Community Power in different towns,
decarbonization in the built sector (while maintaining air quality),
impacting NH energy policy and legislation,
and determining the state's future energy goals.
The proposed agenda for this first meeting:
identifying ourselves, the successes and concerns of the groups we represent, and the hopes we have for this new gathering.
prioritizing goals, and/or setting up subcommittees to pursue different goals
determining the frequency for meeting and a leadership model (rotating leaders?)
Feel free to share this invitation with others. Zoom link below. BTW, please don't hit "reply all". (Send any comments to Susan Richmond, and she will reserve them for this new group's email list.)
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89973064386?pwd=T2tOUmhMa1NWckdiQlAwbXNvWjJyUT09
Meeting ID: 899 7306 4386
Passcode: 673583
Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kcaC4WjPPB
Thursday, October 19 7 to 8 pm. Union of Concerned Scientists
NH Bird Dog Training: How to Ask Candidates Questions on Climate
(Details posted in the Take Action section)
Please register today for our skills-building workshop on birddogging and we hope to see you on October 19.
Register for the skills-building training today.
November 8th 2nd Annual North Country Food and Agriculture Summit is now open!
Please register today. Registration is open until November 1st. Share this invitation with your networks, friends, and co-workers.
Take Action
The next hearing of the NH Committee to Study Extended Producer Responsibility is this Monday, Oct.16 starting at 10:00 AM.
Want talking points? View EXCELLENT TESTIMONY on behalf of EPR
at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bh9csDIvafo
(Our own Kristine Baber is brilliant, and spokesperson for American Beverages also firmly supports EPR!)
PLEASE HELP make this bill a possibility. Take action by following the instructions/talking points on the NH Network's Take Action webpage. Even a brief email to the 4 committee members will help move this effort forward and not let it die in committee.
Please try to attend in person or by using this YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/live/en1FT41qJHA?si=fHtUoAeFglEJu4G6
Transportation Input
Your input wanted -- transportation in NH
Hearings are happening now for the Draft 2025-2034 Ten Year Transportation Plan.
The hearings began 9/7 but continue to 10/25. Here is the link to view the schedule:
https://mm.nh.gov/files/uploads/dot/remote-docs/final-gacit-schedule.pdf
PLEASE FIND ONE YOU CAN ATTEND. At the hearing in Durham, the members of the Governor's Advisory Commission on Intermodal Transportation (GACIT) spoke mostly about expanding and repairing roads, repairing bridges
Written input additionally accepted, through Nov 3, directed to William.e.watsonjr@dot.nh.gov
and there is a survey to fill out at https://metroquestsurvey.com/yn8w8t (The survey is tilted toward road construction & improvement – but there are open comment opportunities.)
AND IF YOU CAN: give oral testimony this Monday the 2nd or Monday the 16th. Both will be in LOB 302 starting at 10:00 and be streamed as well.
Feed Your Brain
This explains the duplicity we get fed from corporations about their efforts at “sustainability.” At least California has pierced the veil.
From NH Energy Education and Action Program (Aubrey Nelson www.nheep.org 603.493.7225)
We are keen to continue to bring energy and climate learning and awareness of green energy careers into classrooms across the state, and we've also started offering programs for adults and families by partnering with community groups, so we’d love for the opportunity to collaborate with you!
NHEEP has traditionally offered hands-on, engaging, NGSS-aligned programs to support energy and climate science/technical learning for students and teachers. Our programs come in a variety of formats:
Hands-on curricular resource and equipment kits (which you can borrow for no or low-cost).
Co-taught workshops (including, but not limited to Green Energy Careers, Electricity & the Environment and Heat Transfer, all of which are free)
Professional development for teachers (there are several free NGSS Toolkit trainings coming up in November in Manchester, Plymouth or online, and these are also free for educators)
Support for teachers and students interested in planning and implementing energy action projects.
High school team action support: Youth Climate Leader’s Academy, which is an engaging year long program to support high school student teams in planning and implementing action projects.
You can visit our website to learn more about our offerings, or call or email me directly. Several of our equipment kits and our co-taught workshops are free thanks to our partnership with NHSaves, so we can discuss what makes the most sense!
From Reinmar
There is considerable public anxiety about a perceived possible or actual wave of e-waste associated with solar panels and their chemical contents. How justified is this really?
Here's a good & very short summary of the research in a new opinion essay published in the journal Nature Physics. And here's a summary by Dan Gearino in Inside Climate News: https://insideclimatenews.org/news/12102023/inside-clean-energy-reality-check-solar-panel-waste/.
Spoiler alert: Anxiety is NOT justified.
The waste produced by other forms of energy generation (not to speak of other petrochemical-related waste such as plastics) is HUNDREDS OF TIMES more problematic.
Solar panels do NOT contain dangerous toxic substances, despite some outdated info on certain US gov't websites.
Commercial solar developers -- unlike producers of plastics and other future waste products -- are legally responsible for the decommissioning process, so they are working to extend the lifetimes of the panels they use, and to reuse the materials in them.
The critical consideration here is that waste streams should ALWAYS be considered upfront in ANY technology. But at this point in history, we must weigh potential problems against each other. The toxic legacy of fossil fuel energy systems is far, far more severe than the relatively manageable challenges of solar panel waste.
Here is the graphic from the Nature Physics paper, which compares different kinds of waste streams over time under "Business As Usual" (that is, if we don't switch away from fossil fuel use) with the possible waste stream from solar energy development: (Unfortunately, this graph cannot be copied into this summary. If you would like to review it then visit the initial email on this thread. https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/43A6KYHAghE
Jon Swan editorial: I believe the NCES Landfill is Failing
I HAVE bad news to share with my fellow Granite Staters. Based on my analysis of groundwater monitoring reports and the historical record, I believe we are witnessing the failure of the controversial NCES Landfill in Bethlehem.
Toxic “forever chemicals” known as PFAS were detected in groundwater at 11 of 19 monitoring wells tested, according to the July, 2023, Tri-Annual Groundwater Monitoring Report, which was submitted to NHDES by Sanborn, Head and Associates (SHA) on behalf of Casella Waste Systems and the NCES Landfill.
Of particular concern is the detection and high level of PFOA, which the EPA is proposing to designate as a hazardous substance under the Superfund law, which would help hold polluters accountable for cleaning up their contamination.
According to the July report, new maximum concentrations of PFOA contaminants were detected in groundwater at two monitoring wells closest to and upgradient of the Ammonoosuc River, which is a mere 550 and 400 feet away.
I’ve analyzed lab results from 2018-2023 for NCES landfill leachate, also known as “garbage juice,” which is trucked in daily by tankers to the City of Concord wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) and the NHDES-operated Franklin WWTP.
Top PFAS compounds present in NCES Landfill leachate also have been consistently detected in groundwater at their various monitoring wells. It appears that the NCES Landfill is failing to contain the leachate it generates, based on the data from both the NCES groundwater monitoring well reports and NCES leachate lab results.
Like DNA in an episode of CSI, the landfill’s leachate seems to match the evidence left behind at the scene, which lies within the watershed of the downgradient Ammonoosuc River.
Unfortunately, the numerous detections of PFAS contaminants in groundwater at NCES have been downplayed in the reports submitted to NHDES since at least 2017, when PFAS testing became a requirement. I believe a false narrative has been relied upon by all parties, to dispel any concerns that the landfill may actually be leaking. Blame is consistently placed on the former Sanco unlined landfill, like an alibi, to explain the presence of contaminants in groundwater at the various monitoring wells outside of the lined landfill. A search of the July 2023 report finds “unlined landfill” comes up 52 times!
The problem with that narrative is that the old Sanco unlined landfill was actually excavated by Casella Construction in the fall of 1993. The waste was relocated to Stage I of the “state-of-the-art”, double-lined landfill, as Casella Waste Systems boasted in Aug. 25, 1993. Ironically, on Nov. 5, 1993, Paul Sanborn, president of Sanborn, Head and Associates (yes, the same company pointing to the “unlined landfill” today), wrote to NHDES to inform them of the completion of the waste-relocation project. He stated residual contamination was not present in the soils in the excavation area, thus clearing the way for NHDES approval for the development of the Stage II landfill expansion over the unlined landfill site.
On Dec. 9, 1993, James Berg of NHDES wrote of the department’s “concurrence” that “no further excavation to remove additional soils is necessary.” In other words, the unlined landfill was excavated of all trash and deemed free of contamination by both SHA and NHDES!
So which is a more plausible source of PFAS and other contaminants: the unlined landfill — excavated 30 years ago and given a clean bill of health by the same engineering firm and NHDES — or are we witnessing the failure of the 36-year old “state-of-the-art” double-liner system of Stage I?
Regardless of cause, the data does not lie. There is a steady release of PFAS and other contaminants from the NCES Landfill into groundwater, all within the watershed of the Ammonoosuc River. Will the EPA investigate? I’ve sent numerous requests, since NHDES appears unconcerned.
Will the Town of Bethlehem become home to a new Superfund site? I don’t see how it doesn’t. The fears and concerns of so many Bethlehem residents over years of contention at growth of this landfill now seem justified, and, sadly, realized.
NHDES failed its mission to protect the environment (and the citizens of Bethlehem). Will Casella be held responsible for the expense of PFAS cleanup and remediation? We shall see; their track record of accepting responsibility is shaky.
It would be irresponsible for NHDES to allow the NCES Landfill to continue to operate, ensuring the continued generation of millions of gallons of leachate annually, which monitoring reports confirm is not being contained. It’s time for NHDES to do its job and close this controversial dump, and potential Superfund site, once and for all.
More from Us and Our Partners
New Hampshire Businesses for Social Responsibility
Find out more and register for this free program which just launched today and runs through December 8th ... www.nhbsr.org/climate
Live Zoom Webinars
October 19, 12:00 - 1:00 PM, Transitioning to Clean Energy and Community Power: Learn the various tax incentives and options.
November 9, 12:00 - 1:00 PM, Resilient and Energy Efficient Buildings: Ask the experts your questions and learn about various new building and existing building strategies.
November 30, 12:00 - 1:00 PM, Hypertherm Associates Panel: Learn how the company integrates its climate strategy through the Green Teams, focuses its climate goals, and its efforts with customers.
December 7, 12:00 - 1:00 PM, Addressing Transportation: EV charging, EV options and strategies for scope 3, NHDES' EMPOWER program.
Topics To Be Discussed:
Week 1: The Business Imperative for Climate Action
Week 2: Assessing Your Business's Climate Footprint and Goal-Setting
Week 3: Energy Efficiency and Transitioning to Clean Sources
Week 4: Industry and Materials
Week 5: Transportation and Mobility Solutions
Week 6: Food, Agriculture, and Land Use
Week 7: Business Resilience and Emergency Management
Week 8: Advocacy and Employee Engagement
October 9 , 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
What’s Happening at the NH Network!
Important message from Reinmar Seidler
Folks,
We should all print out this document (linked below) & hang it in a conspicuous place to remind ourselves: Science is in NO CONFLICT with Spirituality, with History, with Tradition, or with Community.
On the contrary -- all of these good things will be protected and maintained if we can use Science as a creative tool to help us fully imagine, and then construct, the future we want & need.
Science is essentially just a collection of ways to extend our senses -- starting with microscopes and telescopes, and continuing on to global networks of meteorological stations that allow us to collectively observe & measure changes in average temperatures and in the carbon content of the atmosphere.
These things help us get to know our lovely Earth better, and make us aware of large-scale changes and trends otherwise invisible to us.
What possible Deity could object to that?
https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_exhortations/documents/20231004-laudate-deum.html
Overview/Table of Contents
Meetings and Events
Energy Expos, Plastics Working Group, Healthcare Alliance annual meeting and dinner, Nottingham Community Climate meeting.
Take Action
Bird Dog opportunities and Bird Dog training from Union of Concerned Scientists.
Network Volunteers Needed: See Take Action Section
Feed Your Brain
Meetings and Events
Meetings and Events
Oct 14 - 9 AM to 2:30 PM - Bow/Dunbarton/Weare Home Energy Expo.
Noyes Community Center (Dunbarton Elementary School)
20 Robert Rogers Rd, Dunbarton, NH. Just off Dunbarton Town Center & Rt. 13
Come learn how to save energy costs and improve the comfort of your home or business.
Heat Pumps for High Efficiency Heating and Cooling, High Efficiency Water Heaters, Rebate Programs and Incentives, Electric Vehicles and E-Bikes, Community Power and other Local Energy Initiatives, Energy Policy, Composting, Water Testing, and more!
Oct 14 - 9 AM – Noon - Nottingham People and Planet Healing Summit
Nottingham Community Church
For more information contact Peter White 603-895-3857.
Oct 15 - 6 PM Plastics Working Group
Join Zoom Meeting
Oct 18 - 5 to 8 pm - NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action in person dinner and meeting.
Join us to celebrate the accomplishments of the organization over the past year, and hold a strategic planning session for our future.
Healthcare website https://www.nhclimatehealth.org/our-events (Numerous other events are offered.)
Oct 19 - Thursday, 7 to 8 PM. Union of Concerned Scientists
Nov 8 - 2nd Annual North Country Food and Agriculture Summit is now open! Please register today. Registration is open until November 1st. Share this invitation with your networks, friends, and co-workers.
Oct 19 - NH Bird Dog Training: How to Ask Candidates Questions on Climate
Please register today for our skills-building workshop on birddogging and we hope to see you on October 19.
More details below in the Take Action Section
Take Action
As we approach the third anniversary of the Network’s creation, new opportunities and challenges arise. Please review this excerpt from the most recent Steering Committee, and perhaps find an opportunity to participate.
As we approach the third anniversary of the Network’s creation, new opportunities and challenges arise. Please review this excerpt from the most recent Steering Committee, and perhaps find an opportunity to participate.
NHN Steering Committee Minutes Sept 27, 9:00-10:30
Volunteers needed! A number of valuable suggestions have been offered for improving the current work and providing more services for the Network members. Help from members is needed in order to be able to do this. What can you do to help in these areas?
Calendar updates on our website
Legislation tracking: need folks to have ongoing relationships with Reps & Senators, to be able to give weekly reports on:
Plastics (PWG working towards this);
Solid Waste: lots of LSRs, Jon Swan will hold a meeting of an “Environmental Working Group” to watch legislation of solid waste, water/PFAS. Need a co-leader.
Climate: first Wed of month. Oct 4 Climate WG. Bringing in folks from other organizations! Looking for a liaison to inform the group on pending legislation. Email John Gage if interested.
Energy Working Group: The Network has not formally had an Energy WG up to now. Bill Coder announced that Third Act is trying to communicate with the PUC, admiring Community Power as NH’s best solution, more democratic. Need volunteer to track energy legislation.
Legislative Working Group: will continue to coordinate the webpage; follow a more manageable number of bills, and be able to track them across the legislative season.
Asking each WG to follow the bills in their own sector, rather than ask one person to do it all.
Our legislative tracking sheet and weekly emails have been successful in getting folks to testify in person/on-line.
Coordinate with recommendations of other groups.
PLEASE HELP TRACK LEGISLATION if you have contacts in the Legislature.
Funding requests update: A private donor is giving us funds to hire a Communications Assistant for 2 months!!
We’ll need $500 for funding after those 2 months - would welcome another generous private donor.
Thanks to NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action for acting as Fiscal Agent.
Steering Committee members had been personally funding the Communications Assistant this summer.
Have applied for funding from a New England organization; should hear back in December.
Presidential candidate schedules through October 16th.
When possible, attend and pose climate questions.
From the Union of Concerned Scientists October 19th Training Details
The New Hampshire presidential primary season is gaining momentum. Candidates are also vying for positions in the governorship, House of Representatives, and various local and state offices.
In this season, climate disinformation abounds. It's crucial for the people of New Hampshire move through the myths and fabrications (not only on climate change… but also what we’re seeing about solutions!) . Each person has the power to promote awareness and make climate and science central to the conversation by posing thoughtful questions to candidates as they traverse the Granite State.
The Union of Concerned Scientists invites you to join a virtual skills-building workshop on how to “birddog” candidates on climate issues. Birddogging is the art of asking a candidate a question at a town hall, in a diner, or on the street, and capturing their response. Join Jake Roche, Roger Stephenson, other UCS organizers, and fellow supporters to learn how you can be an advocate for science and get candidates on record:
In this workshop, we will cover tangible, real-world instances of birddogging success. You will gain an understanding of why birddogging holds such significance in shaping the dialogue in New Hampshire and how it genuinely drives change. We will explore a range of tactics, from employing the buddy system to help secure the opportunity to be called upon during candidate events.
Please register today for our skills-building workshop on birddogging and we hope to see you on October 19.
Considering acting locally. An email exchange about the deluge of political signs that are forthcoming. Consider checking with your towns and/or candidates.
Political Yard Sign Discussion
Viewpoint #1
Hello gang,
After every election season, we dutiful volunteers collect the corrugated plastic yard signs (and after saving a few to reuse out of the hundreds) we always feel the ravages of the plastic travesty that it is. But off to the trash they go filling up our landfill.
A much better option to the corrugated plastic is the film plastic (like mailer plastic) which stretches over a metal frame and which can be recycled (metal too). This choice alone saves enormous amounts of plastic from landfill. Many yard sign companies offer this alternative but many don't. The film plastic signs are cheaper but not as durable in extreme weather.
Some of you may have figured out other alternatives. In our Democratic group, someone suggested white poster paint and then hand paint a colorful message. This is great for a neighborhood or town that wishes to do this (& the signs would undoubtedly be better noticed) but on a state level this would be impractical and can't be adopted.
I'm wondering if the Plastics Working Group could join me in contacting both the NH Democratic and Republican Party head Quarters to seeing if we could convince them to get word out to all the candidates to use the 'film' plastic signage (over corrugated) in this new pre-election season and do their part for the environment.
I just wrote (below in italix) to a sign company and think we should do this on a much larger scale by contacting the consumers who will be ordering the signs.
What do people think about joining me in coming up with a convincing letter to the 2 parties?
Dear owner/manger,
I am very interested in non-corrugated plastic signage for the coming year's political candidate advertising. I haven't seen the thin ‘film’ plastic alternative on your website.
Have you ever thoughtof what happens to your signs after a few weeks of usage? They fill our landfills and as you state, are durable which means they can take up to 1000 years to break down, becoming microplastics that absorb toxins and continue to pollute the environment. '
Neic.gov.
Please consider using 'film' plastic, which stretches over a metal frame, and which can be recycled and fill this need for those who need to advertise but want to do less damage to our environment.
Advertising it as recyclable (like mailer plastic) can only help your sales I would think. There are a lot of us out there!
Thanks so much for your time.
Viewpoint #2
Hello Everyone,
I have had the opposite experience. I was unable to recycle the plastic film signs from the last election. If anyone knows who will accept this type of signage, please let me know.
On the other hand, UNH Dept. of Occupational Therapy will reuse the corrugated signs. Two years ago I gave them close to 100 signs and they were very grateful.
Feed Your Brain
Read Laudate Deum
https://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/apost_exhortations/documents/20231004-laudate-deum.html
October 1 , 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
It has been mentioned before, but check out Future Crunch for global good news. Here is the most recent weekly update.
This is a long summary due to a bevy of opportunities which, in turn, include detailed actions plans.
THERE ARE A LOT OF UPCOMING MEETINGS AND ACTION OPTIONS. To make the “take action” section more user friendly, here is a brief list of action items. Please note, submissions are all time sensitive. (In depth details offered below.)
-Offer input on the ten year transportation plan
-Encourage NH DES to take action on EV charger stations
-Legislative Extender Producer Responsibility - seeking testimony and input to create a bill for the upcoming session
-Request from Cindy Walter
"I need help for a presentation to NH town officials called 'Hazardous Industries: How Can Municipalities Protect Themselves?’. As a newcomer to NH, I need cases in NH history of problems and successes in managing hazardous industries. So far I have 2 problems: St. Gobain and Groveton’s plastic to fuel plant, and 1 success: Oil refinery that did not locate on Great Bay due to public pressure. Any more?
Meetings
October 3 6:30 pm Climate Cafe in Keene
https://groups.google.com/g/nh-environment-energy-and-climate-network/c/ynQnKJ_U6E0
October 3 and November 11 6 pm Study opportunity to employ community power within Concord
Saturday October 7, 2023 from 10AM-2PM during the Casella "Open House" (from Jon Swan)
Bring a sign, bring your friends and family and join me in a peaceful protest outside of the NCES Landfill at 581 Trudeau Road in Bethlehem, NH We must stand tall to protect our environment and natural resources, and call upon those tasked with protecting both and demand that they do their job!
The landfill is leaking #PFAS and other contaminants, like 1,4-Dioxane, into the watershed of the Ammonoosuc River. Please call NHDES Commissioner Robert Scott and EPA Administrator Michael Regan, and ask them what they are going to do about the PFOA and other "forever chemicals" being released from the landfill via groundwater, as detected by the numerous groundwater monitoring wells at the NCES Landfill site...all of which lies within the watershed of the Ammonoosuc River. Of course, this is merely my opinion, based on my extensive research and the data, as reported by the engineering firm Sanborn, Head and Associates, in the groundwater monitoring reports submitted to NHDES. All of this information is on my website, http://www.SaveForestLake.com
Call NHDES and EPA and ask them what they are going to do about the PFAS contaminants that are leaking from the landfill within the watershed of the Ammonoosic River:
NHDES Commissioner Robert Scott: (603) 271-3503 Email: robert....@des.nh.gov
EPA Administrator Michael Regan: (202) 564-4700 Email: Regan....@epa.gov
Oct 14 9 am to 2:30 pm Bow/Dunbarton/Weare Home Energy Expo.
Noyes Community Center (Dunbarton Elementary School)
20 Robert Rogers Rd, Dunbarton, NH. Just off Dunbarton Town Center & Rt. 13
Come learn how to save energy costs and improve the comfort of your home or business.
Heat Pumps for High Efficiency Heating and Cooling, High Efficiency Water Heaters, Rebate Programs and Incentives, Electric Vehicles and E-Bikes, Community Power and other Local Energy Initiatives, Energy Policy, Composting, Water Testing, and more!
October 6, 12-1PM NH Food Alliance’s 2023-2024 Network Café Series: A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience. -Estimating Resilient Eating Patterns
Volume 1 of A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience examines the question “If we ate in a healthier, more resilient way, could more of our food be supplied by regional production?” Our October Network Café features Brian Donohue of Brandeis University, the leader of the team who researched the answer to this question. The team’s primary work was to analyze dietary patterns across major food groups to better understand the food that New Englanders currently consume—and how that might change by 2030. Join us for an overview of “Volume 1: Estimating Resilient Eating Patterns” with Brian to find out what the team learned and to discuss the research’s implications for New Hampshire's food system.
The NH Food Alliance’s 2023-2024 Network Café Series will explore A Regional Approach to Food System Resilience, a four-volume report of foundational food system data commissioned and released by the New England State Food System Planners Partnership. The New England State Food System Planners Partnership is a collaboration among six state-level food system organizations and Food Solutions New England. The report lays out an unprecedented compilation of the most current New England food systems data and frames the data intentionally to inspire conversation and action towards New England producing and consuming more of its own food.
OCTOBER 14 9:00 AM – NOON NOTTINGHAM COMMUNITY CHURCH
FOR MORE INFORMATION CONTACT PETER WHITE 603-895-3857.
October 15 6 pm Plastics Working Group
Join Zoom Meeting
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/6275609302
October 18 5 to 8 pm NH Healthcare Workers for Climate Action in person dinner and meeting.
Join us to celebrate the accomplishments of the organization over the past year, and hold a strategic planning session for our future.
Healthcare website https://www.nhclimatehealth.org/our-events (Numerous other events are offered.)
Become a Member for more information and to attend!
November 8th 2nd Annual North Country Food and Agriculture Summit is now open!
Please register today. Registration is open until November 1st. Share this invitation with your networks, friends, and co-workers.
NEWS UPDATE
We’ll let you know when/how/where input will be accepted on an updated state climate action plan. The Executive Council awarded the UNH Survey Center the contract to arrange for public input. Here’s a bit of news from NH Bulletin and NHPR: https://www.nhpr.org/nh-news/2023-09-25/with-march-2024-federal-deadline-nh-will-soon-embark-on-climate-plan-outreach (Thanks to Bill Coder for this news.)
DETAILED PLANS FOR ACTION
1. TWO opportunities for input on transportation in NH (do these now!)
ONE: Hearings are happening now for the Draft 2025-2034 Ten Year Transportation Plan.
The hearings began 9/7 but continue to 10/25. Here is the link to view the schedule:
https://mm.nh.gov/files/uploads/dot/remote-docs/final-gacit-schedule.pdf
PLEASE FIND ONE YOU CAN ATTEND. At the hearing in Durham this week, the members of the Governor's Advisory Commission on Intermodal Transportation (GACIT) spoke mostly about expanding and repairing roads, repairing bridges – and, oh yes, airports! Public comments (that included me) talked about needing rail, bus, EV charging, bike paths.
Written input additionally accepted, through Nov 3, directed to Wiliam.e...@dot.nh.gov
and there is a survey to fill out at https://metroquestsurvey.com/yn8w8t (The survey is tilted toward road construction & improvement – but there are open comment opportunities.)
TWO: BEST BY OCTOBER 2
NHDES wants input on the development of a new electric vehicle (EV) charging grant program!
“We want to hear from as many interested parties as possible and are especially interested in hearing from residents of and businesses located in disadvantaged communities, including rural and low-income areas, to learn how we can structure a program that results in those communities benefiting from this investment. Please forward this survey to organizations and individuals that represent such communities as well as others that may be interested in sharing their ideas.”
About the funding: NHDES has applied to the National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure (NEVI) discretionary Charging and Fueling Infrastructure (CFI) program for community-based electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE). If awarded, NHDES plans to release a funding opportunity aimed at installing EV charging stations within communities.
Public comment opportunities: We will be hosting two virtual listening sessions on October 4, 2023 to receive input from the public, one at noon and one at 7:00 PM (Eastern). The listening sessions will be recorded and posted to our webpage. We will also consolidate comments and post them in a document for reference, including our responses if applicable. We invite community organizations to help get input to us from your community members and businesses on how to design a program to enable and support their participation.
How to comment: This is your chance to help shape the program! We welcome comments and input submitted via this form. Comments received by October 2nd will be prioritized and may be directly addressed during the October 4th listening sessions. If time allows, there may also be an opportunity for new comments during the sessions. This form will close on October 6th at 11pm.
Do not suggest a specific site. We will not entertain suggestions of particular places, towns, or businesses. Do not list places we should or shouldn’t consider. Additionally, please do not ask questions about the program. We will not be answering questions about our program or our priorities, as the program is still in development and contingent upon NHDES receiving an award.
Before you comment:
· Please familiarize yourself with NHDES’ VW-funded RFP for EV charging. This may inform development of this RFP.
· Please familiarize yourself with the basics of the NEVI CFI Community program and NEVI Standards and Requirements, including:
o All sites must be able to charge 4 vehicles simultaneously using Level 2, Direct Current Fast Charging (DCFC), or a mix of both;
o DCFC ports must deliver ≥150 kW of charging;
o DCFC ports must have at least a CCS1 connector (can include others too);
o The goal is to serve downtown communities, multi-unit dwellings, rural locations, transit hubs, and tourist attractions.
Register for the October 4th listening sessions:
From the Plastics WG ( two parts)
LESS WASTE for our municipalities to deal with: Please write or give oral testimony to the study committee hoping to create a bill for this year on "Extended Producer Responsibility." EPR would cut down on unnecessary packaging because it asks producers to pay for its end-of-life. There are EPR programs in some US states and the EU. It would spare municipalities from the expense of dealing with this waste, it would diminish plastic in our landfills.
Want talking points? View EXCELLENT TESTIMONY on behalf of EPR at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bh9csDIvafo
(Our own Kristine Baber is brilliant, and spokesperson for American Beverages also firmly supports EPR!)
PLEASE HELP make this bill a possibility - email testimony to
AND IF YOU CAN: give oral testimony this Monday the 2nd or Monday the 16th. Both will be in LOB 302 starting at 10:00 and be streamed as well.
EPR Study Committee Meeting - Monday, October 2, 10 am (Fascinating discussion - nothing is simple, and hopefully you can see a recording)
Watch live here. DES will be testifying. Rep. Parshall (Chair) reports that public testimony is welcome at the upcoming October 16 meeting.
Hidden Brain Podcast - “The Secret to Great Teams"
From 350 NH
The Governor’s Advisory Commission on Intermodal Transportation (GACIT), which is made up of the five Executive Councilors and the Commissioner of the New Hampshire Department of Transportation (NHDOT), has scheduled public hearings throughout the state, starting tomorrow in Salem and running through October (Link to the schedule) to talk about their Ten Year Plan.
The Ten Year Plan includes infrastructure funding - for bridges, roads, rail trails, and airports. What this plan DOESN'T include is public transportation investment or electric vehicle infrastructure. With the climate crisis worsening, we need every facet of our state government to include climate action in their long term planning.
We need your help to turn people out to the hearings to let the EC know what is missing in the current plan and what should be included! People should attend the hearing that is in their Executive Council district. We have also set up a letter-writing campaign HERE.
Plastics WG Opportunity
An Invitation to Participate in a Craftivism Project to Promote Reusable Produce Bags:
Mesh Bag Mama kits are available for anyone who would like to sew a few mesh produce bags to get to 1,000 bags to deliver to the Lebanon Co-op for installation on October 21 as a reusable choice instead of single use plastic bags in the produce section. Email chea...@gmail.com. An educational postcard will be inserted into each bag.
To become involved in assembling the kits (no sewing skills required), the Mesh Bag Mama pop up studio will be open on Mondays and Thursdays, September 11, 14, 18, 21 from 10 am - Noon at the former Cornish General Store on Route 120 in Lebanon. No experience necessary to prepare the kits.
Special thanks to Patsy and Mary for hosting a sewing event on September 29 in Nelson and to the Cornish Quilters, Sustainable Lebanon (sponsor), and St. Paul’s Church sewers for working on the project.
Feed your Brain: Recording of Network OffShore Wind and Fish Sustainability
We regret that due to technical difficulties the recording of the first half of the event is unavailable. We've posted the available recording and presentations at
https://www.newhampshirenetwork.org/events
For our initial presentation on Offshore Wind, you can access the recording of our June 5 event, "Clearing the Fog," which is also available at
September 15, 2023 - Update from Bruce Berk
Lots of opportunities to attend meetings, take action, sew mesh bags(!) and more.