4th Annual Environmental Summit—Saturday, August 23rd at Starr King in Plymouth, NH.
Our objective is to help groups, leaders, and citizens across New Hampshire share information, collaborate, and amplify each others' actions to help address climate pollution at the town, state, and federal levels.
Register to get the Zoom link at bit.ly/2025-cpg-nh
This will be a follow-up discussion about "The Growing U.S. Carbon Price Gap" we discussed last month.
How to prepare for this meeting:
Fossil fuel billionaire Charles Koch is a major investor in Alberta tar sands oil. He is also a founder and funder of some of the most prolific PR organizations that mislead about climate pollution from fossil fuels and policies to address the problem. Those organizations are overwhelmingly influential in our state's energy and pollution policies.
It shouldn't be free to pollute, but fossil fuel billionaire families profit enormously when pollution from the coal, oil, and gas they sell remains free. This is an implicit, annual multi-hundred-billion-dollar subsidy that makes fossil fuels more competitive in the New Hampshire and U.S. economies. Free climate pollution is not just an environmental problem: it is one of our biggest economic challenges. Our opportunity costs from lacking a price signal on climate pollution grow each year, but Koch and his network of billionaires who fund climate science and policy disinformation work to prevent legislation that would create that price signal: desmog.com/2024/10/25/project-2025-trump-mapped-how-6-billionaire-family-fortunes-fund-climate-denial.
Globally, carbon pricing is spreading, prices are rising, and CBAMS and carbon clubs are coming. The U.S. is now the only developed country without a carbon price. The CBAMS of other countries will soon charge free-polluting countries (including the U.S.) for the emissions produced during the manufacture of goods in trade. The largest public statement ever by U.S. economists explains why and how to price carbon emissions: carboncashback.org/carbon-cash-back.
Fossil fuel billionaire money has strongly influenced New Hampshire legislation for years. Read about the $24,000 in reimbursements that one leading New Hampshire State Representative has received from Koch Network-funded front groups, including ALEC, Americans for Prosperity, and Heartland Institute at notnotter.org.
The names and missions of those front groups sound conservative, comforting, and safe. But beneath a thin veneer of conservative values, the groups promote myths, half-truths, and lies about what we know through science about the costs, risks, and losses from fossil fuel climate pollution. The groups work to keep it free to pollute and guide our state in ways that maximize the use of fossil fuels, minimize investments in energy efficiency and deployments of clean energy solutions, and eliminate local control of towns that have ambitions to reduce their climate pollution (a sensible risk-management strategy in anticipation of a future federal carbon price).
Resources:
This one-pager outlines the growing U.S. carbon price gap problem and provides recommendations for addressing it: bit.ly/carbon-price-gap-pdf.
This slide deck expands on those ideas: bit.ly/carbon-price-gap-presentation.
Recording of a breakout session on this topic at the Citizens’ Climate Lobby’s 2025 Northeast Regional Conference: bit.ly/carbon-price-gap-2025.
I shared these resources with every New Hampshire state legislator and invited them to discuss the facts and implications of the growing US carbon price gap in a Q&A Zoom call on Saturday, June 7, or individually if they prefer. Please contact your Reps and encourage them to attend (the time and Zoom link are in the email I sent them). Our next CWG meeting is designed to provide a similar event to the public, taking place on Sunday, June 8, from 7:00 to 8:00 p.m. Please review the “carbon price gap” resources above, then register for our monthly meeting to get the Zoom link at bit.ly/2025-cpg-nh.
2025-01-27 - Concord Monitor LTE: Science denial on the House Science Committee
Concord Monitor & Green Energy Times: Talk Climate With Candidates (and your newly elected leaders!)
Senator Whitehouse describes "The Global Economic Consequences of Climate Change" in his powerful 295th "Time To Wake Up" Senate floor speech.
UN Chief calls for a global ban on fossil fuel advertising: Recording here.
Testimony on HB1486 - relative to proxy carbon pricing in state procurement. Saves taxpayer dollars and takes advantage of the federal subsidies in state spending. This bill will help electrify NH state vehicles (EVs) and state building heating equipment (heat pumps) to reduce pollution from state operations and avoid future stranded assets by anticipating the inevitable federal price on carbon pollution from fossil fuels... thus saving NH taxpayers money!
Proxy carbon pricing one-pager (+ graphs).
Testimony by Rep. Germana, John Gage, and others.
The Growing Carbon Price Gap:
6-minute recording: bit.ly/carbon-price-gap-2024
One-pager: bit.ly/carbon-price-gap-pdf
Google Drive with Carbon Fee and Dividend policy documents: bit.ly/cfdresources
A project for high school or college students: Carbon Fee and Dividend Movement cfdmovement.com
Town warrant article project: "A resolution to take action on climate pollution": carboncashback.org
“The Collapse of Western Civilization, a View from the Future” by Naomi Oreskes. A free download of the book is available here: Free PDF.
Special May event: "The Growing U.S. Carbon Price Gap" presentation: one-pager, slides, and event recording
Agenda and Notes for 2025-04-01
Agenda and Notes for 2025-03-04
Agenda and Notes for 2025-02-04 - on-going state climate legislation, CCAP input
Agenda and Notes for 2025-01-07, Zoom recording, and Zoom chat and AI summary.
Agenda and Notes for 2024-12-3
Agenda and Notes for 2024-10-7
Agenda and Notes for 2024-09-11
Agenda and Notes for 2024-07-10
Agenda and Notes for 2024-06-19: Climate Cafe - how to do one - Recording available here.
Agenda and Notes for 2024-05-08
Agenda and Notes for 2024-04-10
Agenda and Notes for 2024-03-13
Agenda and Notes for 2023-02-14
Agenda and Notes for 2024-01-10
Review the "Keep NH Green" climate group findings and plan next steps. Use this working group as a home going forward?
An En-ROADS climate policy simulator demonstration to help our group gain a shared perspective of what policy changes are required at a global level to achieve our 1.5˚C warming limit. Discuss why the IPCC says carbon pricing must be included in any effective solution set and why Carbon Cash-Back is the most equitable way to do it. Send Congress an email asking them to legislate it via this web action page: cclusa.org/write-cfd.
Discuss potential NH State climate bills for the 2023-2023 legislative session:
Require proxy carbon pricing be used by PUC/SEC/Energy Dept. to avoid costly short-sighted decisions
End ratepayer funding of power company lobbying activities to avoid working against citizen's interests
A resolution (Senate first) calling for the US government to take steps to prepare for the carbon tariff that is coming to us (EU CBAM January 2026, Canada and the UK likely to follow shortly after). The PROVE IT Act is a good first step. A matching federal carbon price would let us avoid paying other countries' carbon tariffs.
Require NASA-based climate science be added to the required curriculum in public schools
A climate science intervention is needed in Concord! Discuss a response to the climate science denial of some leadership in the NH House Science, Technology, and Energy (STE) Committee by asking the Chairman to hold an information gathering hearing with our state's climate science experts, to include a review by the authors of the state's 2022 Climate Assessment Report and evaluation by state experts of the co-sponsors' HR17 testimony. Let's help clear up the misunderstandings so the STE can make better informed decisions for all of us! A request sent to the legislature: Request for a climate science intervention in the STE.
What are NH Network member groups doing on climate: major initiatives, events, how can others help?
We'll focus on making climate a top-level issue in the upcoming election cycle, and look at how AI can help us do it. The NH Network is a nonpartisan group, but our elected leaders' priorities are the single biggest factor in how effective all our efforts are to address climate issues in our towns, the state, and beyond. The vast majority of NH voters want climate change addressed (see the Yale Climate Communications report at bit.ly/ccb-resources). Helping them learn candidates' positions will help them choose wisely, and motivate candidates to care too.
Agenda:
1. NHPR is asking what listeners want to hear candidates talk about. We can each let NHPR know we want to hear candidates' positions on climate change and Carbon Cash-Back! Tell NHPR you want this here: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdoSGnepE958a9NqBVOEwHvVRcTlZAXBeeCVu96Y7ATzL4LPQ/viewform?pli=1.
2. Help get our local media more involved in informing the state about climate solutions: CCL's media expert offers some suggestions and actions to take: https://community.citizensclimate.org/discuss/viewtopic/2792/31110
3. Engaging in 2024 campaign town halls and house parties: raising fossil fuel pollution-caused global heating to a top-level issue - Engaging Candidates in Climate.
4. Send a quick email to Congress via cclusa.org/prove about the PROVE IT Act - a no-brainer, bipartisan bill everyone loves!
5. We'll explore how we can use AI (ChatGPT) to help write LTEs, op-eds, and even plan presentations (openai.com).
I hope to see you there,
John Gage
Windham, NH
Discuss potential legislation to propose for the fall.
Please also see below for an action for everyone to take whether you can attend the meeting or not. We'll start off our meeting with a discussion about the big climate picture:
This amazing podcast puts the whole climate mess into perspective and offers suggestions about how we might make bipartisan policy progress here in the US as is being done in other countries: Outrage and Optimism podcast, "Lifelines VS Deadlines: The Need For Science-Based Policy" podcast: Naomi Oreskes, Senator Whitehouse, and other experts on the climate crisis - https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9vdXRyYWdlYW5kb3B0aW1pc20ubGlic3luLmNvbS9yc3M/episode/MzlkYWZhNjctZGIxYy00MzNlLWJkOTItYzU3NTE2YTU0NmNm?ep=14
This video tells the American story of how one man played a pivotal role in our failure to address climate change decades ago when there was strong bipartisan support to do so (John Sununu) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hvGQMZFP9IA.
Let's talk about the different aspects of the problem, why New Hampshire continues to play a pivotal role in the whole global mess, and how we can help turn things around.
Matt wrote this excellent op-ed to help the public become more aware of the forces that are stymying decarbonization of the New Hampshire economy: How to move beyond climate disinformation in the N.H. State House. How can we amplify this message?
We'll then take some climate actions to help prepare Congress for CCL's in-person lobbying on Capitol Hill on June 13th. Four people from NH will join 900 others from around the country to lobby hundreds of Congressional offices for bipartisan clean energy permitting reform and introduction of the federal Carbon Cash-Back bill in the new session of Congress.
The more emails and calls from constituents that precede those June 13th lobby meetings, and the more constituent postcards we deliver in person, the more attention Congress will give us. If you can't make our meeting tomorrow, please help prepare Congress for our lobby meetings by doing one or more of the following:
Ask Congress to support Carbon Fee and Dividend legislation: (email via this webform) cclusa.org/write-cfd or (call) cclusa.org/call. (If you call, start with the suggested script and then finish by asking your Representative to become a co-sponsor of the Energy Innovation and Carbon Dividend Act and ask your Senators to talk about the Carbon Fee and Dividend policy with their colleagues and prepare to introduce a bipartisan bill to do it in their chamber too).
Or, if you prefer, write a quick note we can hand-deliver. Using the attached Postcard PDF, update the document and send me a PDF that I will print three copies of to bring to Washington. We'll hand-deliver your message to your Congressional delegation when we meet with them! Each page has 4 postcards - ask your family and friends to fill out one card each on the page too, and share the PDF via email. It's possible to use a PDF editor to update the document directly, or you can print it, fill it out, and scan it back in. Return filled-in PDFs to me via email, or mail printed copies to me at "John Gage, 12 Fordway Extension, Windham, NH. 03087").
If you know (or are) a community leader, state representative, business owner, or another prominent individual (or you are one), please use the second attached PDF to generate an endorsement of the Carbon Fee Dividend policy. Or you can use the online form to do this at cclusa.org/endorse. Endorsements are another important part of demonstrating the political will in NH for a federal Carbon Fee and Dividend legislation. See the NH endorsement map for a (partial) list we'll be delivering (near the bottom of carboncashback.org).
All these messages will amplify our impact when we meet Congress on June 13th.
Thank you for all you do. I hope you can make it Wednesday at 5:00 pm!
Best Regards,
John Gage
NH Network Climate Working Group co-leader
CCL NH state coordinator
Windham, NH
NH Network Climate Working Group interest form: https://forms.gle/reaNRxP4cdK7gZZq8
Nat Geo’s Years of Living Dangerously "Safe Passage" episode (on Citizens’ Climate Lobby): https://youtu.be/bW-TDUZOTRo
From John Gage: Topics to discuss with our legislators
1. Do you accept the scientific consensus that human-caused climate change is an urgent threat?
2. Do you accept the expert consensus of climate scientists and economists that effective government action to reduce climate pollution much faster than the current rate is critical for the safety of our economy, health, and life on Earth?
3. Are you committed to work with members of both parties and Independents on legislative solutions to address the issue?
4. Did you know the most well-supported solution by economists from across the political spectrum - a border-adjusted, cash-back carbon fee on fossil fuel production - is the most cost-effective and equitable policy approach?
Carbon Cash-Back Resources: http://bit.ly/ccb-resources
From Phil Browne to Everyone: Blend as many of the organizations that are involved in issues related to human and biosphere survival as possible with a common goal of creating a lobbying group of NH college students who will get college credit for their efforts as well as as a stipend/salary for their time. We can then use our common knowledge to train them to address our multi-group common goals. They will then reach out to: Town Meetings, Conservation commissions, School Boards, K-12 Faculty Meetings, Rotary and other clubs, NH Science Teachers, Promote “Survival Days” at colleges and universities in order to get students involved “Act Out” to get their message picked up by media ( like protestors in Iran). This will then filter down to High School students and through them their families to get the message out.
Join online: https://citizensclimate.zoom.us/my/cclnhrizoom?pwd=MTRoSmtMQ3J3bksyc0xwVk9sbEJMdz09
Or at Zoom.us with Meeting Id: 9831200408 Passcode: 1632
Or by phone: 1-929-205-6099 9831200408# 1632#
Let's convene members from the various groups working on local, state, and federal climate solutions today and talk about collaborating and amplifying each others projects' impacts. If time allows, we'll also discuss Koch Network's influence on NH climate ambitions.